Tommy

Would You Rather · Episode 29

Holiday Auction

1,901 words

Get ready, Tommy the Hamburger is about to twist your motherfucking brain. You're going to get two choices, and an examination of the fucking thought process behind both. Shit's about to get detailed and complicated, so you better pay attention. All right. Here is the motherfucking dilemma. Would you rather auction your holiday attendance to the highest bidding relative, or commit to hosting every holiday forever? I am standing in a kitchen that has gone past festive and entered hostage territory. It smells like scorched pie crust and ham glaze, with dish soap and stale wine sitting under the greasy electrical stink of too many warming trays plugged into too few safe outlets. Every counter is crowded. Every chair is spoken for. There are place cards on the table like little threat notes. On one side of the room a stack of bidding paddles and envelopes sits beside a brass hand bell somebody brought with entirely too much enthusiasm. On the other side there is the giant folding table where I am apparently supposed to keep doing this forever if I pick the martyr option. Fuck me sideways, one side of the choice turns me into a seasonal luxury item. The other side turns my house and body into permanent holiday infrastructure. Option one is Holiday Auction. Relatives bid for my attendance, and whichever branch pays the most gets me in the room and in the photos while everybody else either loses out or gets scraps of my time. Option two is Eternal Host. I lock myself into being the site and labor pool for every major holiday, every year, with no real way out and no chance to show up empty handed and just be a person for once. This is not a warm family question. This is a choice between selling my presence or donating my life to the logistics of everybody else's sentiment. Let me drag Holiday Auction under the light first. I know why it has appeal. There is a mean little honesty to it. Families already play this game in soft language. They argue about who is expected where and whose feelings matter most, while every relative reaches for whatever guilt lever looks strongest that year. An auction just strips off the fake lace and admits what the whole rotten system already is. If you want my time so badly, then stop calling it duty and start showing me what it is worth. That is the false hope in this option. The auction says if I price my attendance, I get control back. I stop being guilt labor and start being a scarce asset. Maybe the wealthier uncle finally pays for all the years he expected me to fly out on my own dime. Maybe the cousin who always says family is everything gets exposed the second money enters the room and folds like cheap laundry. I start thinking I can stop getting dragged around by emotional blackmail and make everybody else admit they were never talking about love without calculation anyway. That part is seductive. It feels like revenge with invoices. The body cost is still ugly. Auctioning my presence means every holiday becomes precombat. The nervous system stays lit because before I even walk into a room, I know there were bids and losers, with resentments and a dollar value attached to where my ass ended up sitting. The relatives who lost the bid do not just disappear. They simmer. They text, and then they passive aggressively mention what they would have cooked if I had chosen them. So even the winning room does not feel like peace. It feels like purchased terrain with snipers in the hills. The emotional cost is worse because the auction does not just expose the transactional nature of family. It deepens it. Once my presence has a number on it, every smile gets contaminated. I start wondering whether a hug is for me or for the money spent, and whether I am really here as myself or just as proof that one branch of the family had stronger leverage this year. People think pricing something forces honesty. Sometimes it just poisons whatever honesty was left. The social trap gets elaborate fast. The family will not leave the auction simple. There will be bidding alliances and quiet side deals after the bell, and the whole clan will start campaigning over who deserves me most. Before long the holidays become a market calendar with loyalty auctions and whisper campaigns. I stop being a person in a family and become a contested booking. The system cost is exactly what every market does once you let it inside the house. It expands. First it is my attendance. Then they start haggling over hours and labor, treating every extra scrap of access like another product line. People start asking for premium tiers because once a family learns how to price access, it starts trying to price intimacy itself. That is not freedom. That is turning love into ticketing infrastructure. Still, Holiday Auction has one brutal advantage over Eternal Host. The labor is visible and finite. I can name the price and set the terms. After that I leave on my own feet with full knowledge of who paid and what the arrangement was. It is disgusting, but the edges are visible. A visible insult can still be fought. Now let me tear into Eternal Host, because this one hides under virtue and eats your spine. Eternal Host says the family should always have one reliable center, and that center should be me. That sounds generous if you are the kind of motherfucker who has never been voluntold into scrubbing a roasting pan at one in the morning while your guests stumble out full and grateful for work they did not do. What it really means is I become the standing venue for every annual emotional collision this bloodline cannot stop staging. That is the false hope in this option. Hosting forever says maybe if the room is always mine, I get some control over the chaos. Maybe the family finally appreciates what it costs. I can almost fool myself into thinking that becoming the permanent center would stop everybody else from yanking me around by their schedules. That sounds good for about ten seconds until you remember what families do to a reliable person. They mount expectations on them like antlers. The body cost on this side is relentless because hosting is not an event. Hosting is a cycle. You spend days getting the place ready and answering everybody's little needs before the guests even hit the door. By the time the leftovers are handled and the trash is hauled out, the next holiday is already walking up the driveway. That kind of repetition wears a man down through the joints until the back starts barking and sleep goes thin. The emotional cost is a slow poisoning. Eternal hosts are expected to feel rewarded by everyone else's comfort. You are supposed to take satisfaction from being useful while your own holiday disappears into labor. Resentment grows in weird quiet corners until even the doorbell starts sounding like a demand. The people who arrive empty handed but full of opinions become unbearable, and every speech about tradition starts sounding like code for keep serving. The social trap is what keeps the whole thing running. Once I host more than once, the family starts speaking as if I was born with oven mitts attached. Then my house becomes the default. If I ever try to stop, people do not hear exhaustion. They hear betrayal. Even relatives with better setups somehow cannot host because I already do it so well. That is the curse of competence in a family. The moment you prove you can carry a burden, the burden gets renamed as your role. The system cost is bigger than one holiday. An eternal host becomes the family archive and emotional trash compactor for the whole clan. If I change a recipe or move a chair, suddenly I am accused of disrespecting tradition, and any real boundary gets treated like sabotage. That is how domestic labor gets turned into a bloodline office nobody admits is an office because then they would have to admit it deserves wages or rotation or mercy. But Eternal Host does have one hard advantage over the auction. The family stays physically together in one stable place, and that continuity is real. I am not too proud to admit it has value. It just costs way too much when one person is expected to pay it forever. The room proves the whole thing while I stand here. Somebody already moved my knives without asking because apparently a kitchen is public property once it becomes holiday central. One aunt is talking about next year like I already agreed. The bell beside the paddles catches the light and looks stupidly cheerful, like monetizing love is somehow less obscene than institutionalizing unpaid labor. Those are the two masks in front of me. One tells me to sell my presence. The other tells me to surrender my house. So let me walk both endings all the way out. If I choose Holiday Auction, I get paid, and I get the ugly satisfaction of making the family admit this was always a contest. It also gives me leverage. I still turn myself into a seasonal product and teach everyone around me that access to me is just another commodity to budget for. That is a trap with receipts. If I choose Eternal Host, I keep the family in one place and the rituals stable, but I become permanent infrastructure for a machine that eats labor and calls the eating love. That is the worse trap. That is slower death with oven heat and polite applause. I choose Holiday Auction. I choose it because I would rather put a fucking price on the scam everybody is already running than let one more motherfucker turn my house into a forever altar of unpaid service. If they want me there, they can admit what they are asking for. I can survive being commodified louder than I can survive being quietly consumed. Eternal Host is the loser because it hides exploitation inside praise and trains one family member to confuse self erasure with generosity. It tells every lazy motherfucker at the table that tradition is most beautiful when somebody else does all the lifting. That is slower death with casserole dishes. So I pick up the little brass bell, ring it once hard enough to cut through every side conversation in the room, and tell them if my holiday presence means that much, then they can stop pretending this was ever about pure love and start bidding in daylight. I tell the loudest aunt in the room that no, she does not get volunteer labor by invoking grandma's recipes like scripture. I tell the cousins if they want tradition preserved, then they can either pay for my time or learn what a mop and a roasting pan feel like in their own hands. Then I clear a space on the counter, set the bell down beside the paddles, and let the whole stupid room hear the honesty it spent years dodging. That's the fucking verdict. I made the call, and if your brain still works, you know where this lands.