Tommy

Would You Rather · Episode 45

Politeness Duel

2,461 words

Get ready, Tommy the Hamburger is about to twist your motherfucking brain. You're going to get two choices, and an examination of the fucking thought process behind both. Shit's about to get detailed and complicated, so you better pay attention. All right. Here is the motherfucking dilemma. Would you rather fight an influencer in a politeness duel with judges, or ghost them and accept a perpetual voicemail curse? I am standing in a velvet performance room that wants to look elegant while it does filthy work. Two podiums face each other on a little circular stage under hot white lights. The carpet smells like makeup powder and old champagne. There is citrus cologne hanging in the air from the front row where a bunch of overdressed vultures are waiting to watch somebody smile themselves to death. Behind them sits a crescent desk full of judges with score paddles and little earpieces like this is some sacred cultural ritual instead of manners wrapped around humiliation. Fuck me sideways, this place feels like a torture chamber built by polite rich freaks. The air is cold from the vents, but the lights hit like fever. My shirt is already sticking between the shoulder blades while my face feels dry and tight from stage powder. I can hear the scoring system chirp whenever some tech in the booth tests the feed. Bracelets clink in the front row. Somebody coughs into silk. There is a tray of bottled water waiting by the curtain like medicine for people about to say fake nice things until their souls fall out. Every detail in here says the same ugly thing. They want conflict, but only if it comes dressed for dinner. Politeness Duel means I stand across from some influencer peacock and compete in rounds of escalating courtesy. I cannot insult or snap, and I sure as hell cannot answer sharp with sharp. I have to flatter, defer, and wrap every ugly instinct in expensive little ribbons until one of us cracks. The judges score warmth, poise, word choice, composure, and whether the fake sincerity reads clean enough to sell. Voicemail Curse means I ghost the whole setup and refuse the stage, but in return every ignored call and message from that influencer starts looping back in my skull later. Miss enough and my brain turns into a private call center full of bait, guilt, little wounded manipulations, and smug little voice notes hitting at the worst possible hours. Both sides are rotten in a very specific way. One side breaks the mouth in public. The other side contaminates silence until even a quiet room feels occupied. One turns me into a decorative liar under bright lights. The other turns my own private hours into rented space for some self branding little parasite. That is why this one bites so hard. I am not just choosing between public shame and avoidance. I am choosing whether the damage lands in the open or crawls inside and starts living there. Let me walk into Politeness Duel first because that trap is immediate and disgusting. The first thing it steals is honest reflex. If somebody says something smug, the body wants to answer in its own language, maybe sharp or dirty or exactly as mean as the moment earned. The duel says no. Dress it up. Put lace on the blade. Thank them for their perspective while the insult crawls across your teeth trying to get out. That split between instinct and performance is already a sick job for a nervous system. Then the scoring makes it worse. Once judges are involved, every sentence becomes labor. I am not speaking to say what is real. I am speaking to satisfy metrics and wondering whether the smile looked warm enough or the pause looked respectful enough, whether the phrasing came off graceful enough to make strangers feel superior. That kind of pressure gets under the skin fast. The body starts monitoring itself from the inside. Even my face and breath begin to feel like equipment I am supposed to manage while somebody across from me is trying to win by being the better ornamental fraud. That is the thing I hate most about this side. It trains a person toward decorative dishonesty. The better fake wins. The cleaner mask wins. Conflict gets drained of blood and replaced with scented syrup so the audience can feel civilized while watching two people try to suffocate each other with manners. It is not about truth. It is about who can hide their real temperature longest while collecting points for elegance. That is a filthy use of language. The emotional cost builds fast because fake politeness does not discharge anger. It stores it. The influencer says some condescending little poison line about my courage or my audience or my so called authenticity, and I have to answer with a gracious smile and some elevated phrase that pretends I did not hear the poison at all. So the anger has nowhere to go. It sits in the chest and hardens. By round three the whole body feels like a sealed boiler with flowers painted on the outside. There is social damage too. If I do well, people will call me gracious. They will mean it as praise. It is not praise. It means they watched me get bent into a shape they find easier to consume. They get to celebrate poise instead of wrestling with what is actually being fought over. Even winning would leave a film on me. I become a little easier for polite predators to imagine owning. That is the humiliation hidden inside the compliment. The influencer angle makes it dirtier because that motherfucker lives on brand control. This is their home turf. Influencers know how to turn insincerity into glow while flattering and humiliating at the same time, and they know how to say something foul in a soft tone that makes the audience blame the reaction instead of the strike. They sell edited calm for a living. Politeness Duel is practically their religion. I would be stepping into a ring where the scoring system already speaks their first language. Still, this side keeps one ugly strength alive, and I have to be honest about it. The damage happens in the open, with judges and audience and fake rules all sitting there in plain view. If I crack, everybody sees the machine that cracked me. If I survive, maybe I can push some real heat through the costume and make the room feel how false the whole setup is. Corrupted speech is still speech. That matters. Now let me sit in Voicemail Curse, because this one fools people by starting with avoidance. Fine, ghost them and let the phone scream into the dark. Sounds easy if your brain is soft enough to trust distance. The curse exists to punish exactly that idea. The messages do not stay outside. They come back later in the skull. You hear the missed calls in the shower, then the playback while parked outside the grocery store, and after that the sweet fake wounded tone right when you are about to fall asleep. Suddenly silence is not silence anymore. It is a delivery system. The body cost there is slower and meaner than the duel. Sleep gets chopped up. The shoulders learn to brace before the phone even moves. Appetite changes because dread changes appetite. The jaw works overtime because the body starts preparing for contact that is not even happening in the room yet. Pretty soon the nerves stop distinguishing between actual vibration and anticipated intrusion. That is what makes the curse so filthy. It teaches the body to fear the gap as much as the message. And the curse does not stop when the lights go down because there are no lights. There is just ordinary life with rot slipped inside it. One message sounds hurt enough to twitch guilt, and the next one sounds mocking enough to spark rage before another goes sweet in that strategic little way manipulative people go sweet when they smell weakness. The voice keeps changing shape to make sure nothing inside me ever settles. That is not one punishment. That is drip feed conditioning. The emotional cost gets uglier because unfinished contact always grows in the imagination. A ghosted person becomes bigger in the head than they were in the room. The mind starts helping with the curse. It invents what the next voicemail might say, rehearses responses I am never going to send, and replays alternate endings where I answered once or answered better. Soon it is not just their voice haunting me. It is my own mind doing overtime on their behalf. Socially, this side rots life in a quieter way. Friends notice I am half present, and I start missing jokes because the playback keeps cutting in while work slips from concentration breaking at random hours. People ask what is wrong and I have no clean answer because how do I explain that some ghosted little brand goblin now rents attic space inside my head. The outside may look calmer than a judged duel, but the damage spreads farther because it leaks into everything. There is false hope here too. The curse whispers that at least I kept my authenticity because I refused the stage. Bullshit. Private suffering is not purity. A person can refuse public humiliation and still get deformed in secret. That might even be worse because nobody else sees the machinery doing its work. They just meet the thinner, meaner, more distracted version of you later and wonder why you have started looking haunted by air. Politeness Duel has false hope of its own, of course. It pretends controlled civility is mastery. It pretends if I can out grace the enemy then I somehow proved character. No. A contest scored by decorum measures adaptation to a fake code. It rewards people who can launder aggression through silk. It rewards those nasty little smiles that say I am cutting your throat with etiquette, and you had better thank me for the form. That is not mastery. That is polished evasion. So the real question is which trap leaves Tommy with enough spine and enough mental room to stay Tommy afterward. The duel humiliates me, yes, but it does it in one bounded event. The voicemail curse invades the hours nobody can defend for me. It turns solitude into contaminated ground. I trust myself more inside a rigged room with witnesses than inside a long private haunting that teaches the nerves to live on alert. I keep looking at the podiums and the judges and asking what kind of creature this room is trying to breed. The answer is obvious. It wants conflict without visible mess. It wants domination that can still wear cuff links. That disgusts me. Still, at least the mechanism stands in the open where I can stare at it. The curse wants something filthier. It wants my own imagination helping with the punishment. It wants me collaborating with the harm by sheer exhaustion. That is the nastier theft. Think about the trigger pattern. Politeness Duel triggers during direct contact. I hear the line, I answer the line, and the damage lands live. Voicemail Curse triggers in absence, with no room and no audience and damn sure no warning. It can hit while I am buying milk or rinsing a glass or lying in bed with the whole house quiet. A live opponent can be read. An absence that speaks from inside the head is harder to fight because it never fully steps into view. It just keeps arriving. Escalation makes the difference even clearer. In the duel, escalation is theatrical. The compliments get sweeter while the poison gets more veiled and the audience gets hungrier for a crack in the mask. Fine. Ugly, but trackable. In the curse, escalation is feral. One message becomes ten. Ten becomes patterns. Patterns become conditioning. Before long the phone buzzes and the stomach drops, and maybe the screen is blank but the body still reacts because the curse taught it to. That is rewiring, not embarrassment. And I know my own limits. If I took the curse, there would come a point where I would start losing fights with air. I would answer ghosts in the shower and mutter rebuttals at red lights until I was carrying around the voice of some smug digital peacock like it was a parasite tucked behind my eyes. That is too much room given to somebody who does not deserve one inch of my inner life. I would rather let an audience watch me grind my teeth through fake courtesy for an hour than give a ghosted clown permanent office space inside my skull. The show side matters too. If I choose Politeness Duel, the machine stays in the room where the judges are visible and the rules can be heard while the rot happens live. If I choose Voicemail Curse, the rest of life becomes the set. The pressure goes private and starts eating the floorboards when nobody is around. That is worse for me. I need the pressure where I can stare at it, not buried in the aftermath where it turns inward and starts breeding. So I am making the call. I choose Politeness Duel. I choose it because however fake and degrading it is, it still happens in the open and leaves me one thing the curse does not. I get a live opponent I can read and a real room I can push against, with rules I might even be able to insult from inside the performance. I would rather stand under bright lights saying unnaturally gracious shit to an influencer motherfucker than spend a year letting unanswered contact rot my sleep from the inside out. Voicemail Curse loses because it is a fucking humiliation machine built from avoidance and repetition with a steady psychological drip feed. It does not just punish one refusal. It teaches the body to live inside anticipated intrusion. It lets one ignored little bastard keep showing up in the skull long after he should have been buried under digital dust. That is slower death. That is the trap that keeps charging rent against your peace. Politeness Duel is still ugly. It still asks me to wear courtesy like a borrowed mask and smile through poison for the pleasure of judges. But it ends. The room sees it. The pressure has edges. I can take one public deformation better than a year of private haunting. I pick the duel and reject the curse. That's the fucking verdict. I made the call, and if your brain still works, you know where this lands.