Would You Rather · Episode 48
Grandma Dunk Tank
2,274 words
Get ready, Tommy the Hamburger is about to twist your motherfucking brain. You're going to get two choices, and an examination of the fucking thought process behind both. Shit's about to get detailed and complicated, so you better pay attention.
All right. Here is the motherfucking dilemma.
Would you rather dunk your grandma at a charity festival, or let the board of directors dunk you while shareholders cheer?
I am standing on a festival lot that smells like fryer grease and wet plywood with trampled grass baking under bad extension cords. The dunk tank sits in the middle like some cheap little altar built for public humiliation. Carnival lights blink around the rim. Somebody hung a smiling family banner over the booth, which only makes the whole thing filthier because now the lie is dressed up as wholesome. Off to one side there is a donor tent with cold water and linen tablecloths. Off to the other side there is a raised platform where the board can sit in shade and watch like Roman trash in golf shirts. Fuck me sideways, the whole place feels like morality with a ticket booth attached.
The air is sticky enough to wear. My shirt is already damp between the shoulders. A generator keeps coughing behind the funnel cake stand. Kids are screaming by the ring toss. Every few seconds the tank gives a little slosh against the wall like it already knows somebody is going in and does not care who. The loudspeaker hisses between announcements. A barker keeps working fake excitement into the microphone. Everywhere I look, the setup is telling the same ugly story. Somebody's dignity is about to get sold for a cheerful cause and a clean little number on a board.
Grandma Dunk Tank means I put my own grandmother on that folding seat above the water and take the throw that drops her in. Not some performer playing sweet old lady for the crowd. My actual grandma. The woman who fed me and covered for me, and who probably still thinks some piece of me can be redeemed. Board Dunk means I climb into the tank myself while the directors line up with baseballs and the shareholders watch from the tent. Every hit sends me into the water while they grin and call it culture. Every miss just buys them another chance to perform ownership with a smile on.
Those are the traps. One turns blood loyalty into a public laugh. The other turns hierarchy into a carnival game with my body at the bottom of the splash. One says family can be converted into charity content. The other says employment can be turned into ritual degradation if the branding is bright enough. Neither one is clean. Neither one is funny. Both were designed by people who think affection and labor are just two more things you can harvest if the crowd is in a good mood.
Let me walk into Grandma Dunk Tank first because this side is morally filthy before the ball ever leaves my hand. I do not care how many ribbons they tie on it or how many donation thermometers they put nearby. It is still me taking aim at the woman I should be protecting. She can agree to it and laugh through it and tell me it is for the kids or the dogs or whatever noble little mascot they put on the flyer. The structure of the act is still betrayal. The room is being invited to enjoy the temporary helplessness of somebody who should be above this.
The body knows it too. You wrap your hand around the ball and everything from shoulder to stomach starts arguing with the motion. The target is wrong, not difficult. Wrong. There are moments when the body has better ethics than the speech around it, and this is one of them. The arm does not want to follow through. The chest does not want to be the engine that sends her down. That resistance matters. It tells the truth the posters refuse to say.
Then there is what grandma actually means. She is not just an elderly person in a seat. She is stored mercy. She is rides home and food when the rest of the day treated you like a stray dog, and she is those old stories that made the room feel safe again. She is the soft place that kept showing up even when you did not deserve it. If I dunk her for applause and charity money, I am not just committing one indecent act. I am telling myself that all of that stored loyalty can be suspended for the length of a laugh. That choice would rot memory from the inside.
The social damage would spread through family like spilled gasoline. The crowd might laugh and the clip might travel, and then strangers start calling it iconic because they are too dead inside to hear what really happened. Fine. Let them. Family still gathers and people still talk, and the cousins will remember. Some uncle who already thought I was a piece of shit finally gets proof framed in water and applause. Every family table after that would contain the fact that Tommy once chose a clean public bit over grandma's dignity. That stain does not wash out because some charity cashed the checks.
There is false hope in this side too, and it is the kind people use when they want permission for something indecent. People tell themselves consent saves it, or that grandma agreeing somehow shrinks the wound, or that enough money raised means the betrayal stops counting. Bullshit. Consent can soften some harm. It does not magically cleanse a spectacle built on humiliating somebody you are supposed to shield. People love hiding behind willingness when they are trying to perfume something rotten.
Still, I have to admit the strength in this side. It is one event, one shame spike, then the ugly thing is over instead of becoming a ritual that keeps repeating for whoever signs the checks. If I took this path, the damage would be catastrophic but finite. There is a before and after. That matters, because repeated humiliation under power has a different stink that gets into the bones and stays there.
Now let me stand in Board Dunk. This one looks cleaner because at least the body in the water is mine. Fine. Better my skin than grandma's. But let us not get stupid about it. That does not make it noble. The whole point of this side is that the men above me get to perform power physically while shareholders applaud from the shade. They stand there in their polos and loafers taking turns at the target attached to my seat while somebody calls it team spirit. The ritual says the same ugly thing every time. We stay dry. You fall.
The body cost is cold and repetitive. Dunk tank water always lies about itself. It looks playful and feels like a sour mix of algae and metal with a weak chlorine edge that never quite wins. Every drop shocks the breath. Every climb back onto the seat reminds the room that I am the one with the target bolted under me. Maybe the first plunge gets a laugh. By the fourth or fifth, it is no longer about novelty. It is about conditioning. I am the object while they keep throwing, and the crowd learns the structure while pretending to enjoy a joke.
That hierarchy lesson is what makes this side so nasty. The board stays dry up on the shaded platform above the whole mess. I am the wet proof that authority gets to make amusement out of the people below it. Everybody watching gets taught that humiliation can be called healthy if the invitations are embossed enough. That is not just a fundraiser. It is a brand safe obedience ritual.
The emotional damage comes from repetition and forced participation. After the first hit maybe I can laugh. After the next few, the laugh turns into management. I start arranging my face for cameras. I start helping the room believe the ritual is harmless because that is what good sports are supposed to do. That is where the real filth lives. Not only in the drop, but in the expectation that I help polish it while it happens.
Socially, Board Dunk can warp how everybody sees me. Some idiot calls it toughness and soon somebody else starts selling it as loyalty until the whole room acts like Tommy is just a company guy who knows his place. All of that is fake praise covering the same ugly picture. A man turned into a toy for his own superiors while the people with real power stay dry and photogenic. That is the kind of image institutions love because it makes submission look cheerful. I hate that. But at least the ugliness stays on the system too. At least the ritual exposes the board as the type of people who need a tank to enjoy themselves.
There is false hope here too, sure. It says maybe by taking the dunk myself I keep the moral center cleaner. Partly true, but only partly. Repeated voluntary self humiliation under power leaves marks. It teaches accommodation and trains the body to keep smiling while the wrong people throw, and then the room learns that if the packaging is playful enough, superiority gets to become public sport. That stain is real. I am not pretending otherwise.
So the real question is not which side is gentler. Neither one deserves that word. The real question is which one does less permanent corruption to the parts of Tommy that still need to stay alive. Blood loyalty matters. So does resistance to structured humiliation. One side blows a hole through family trust. The other side lets power stage itself through my body. I have to choose which ruin I would rather live near afterward.
I keep looking between the folding seat and the donor tent and asking who benefits from each arrangement. Grandma Dunk Tank feeds the crowd's appetite for transgression. They get the thrill of seeing somebody cross a line they still want credit for recognizing as a line. Board Dunk feeds hierarchy more directly. It gives executives a playful public tool for reminding everybody who gets to stand and who gets to splash. That second function scares me because it scales. Once power learns a cute way to humiliate, it starts wanting more of it.
Think about escalation. Grandma Dunk Tank peaks fast. It happens once, and the family memory never dies. Board Dunk does not peak so neatly. One director throws, then another, and if they miss the room starts begging for extra tries until somebody drags a shareholder up there for a laugh or demands one more plunge because the donation board is close to the next target. This ritual can keep extending as long as the room stays amused. That repeatability is what makes it dangerous. It is not one indecent act. It is infrastructure.
And I know my own limit here. If I watched my grandmother drop because my hand made it happen, I would hear that splash in my ribs forever. I do not care how saintly the beneficiary list looked afterward. That sound would live there. If I let the board dunk me all afternoon, I come away carrying something different. Not blood guilt, but contempt, slow and hot, for every smiling bastard who told me to take the joke because it was good for the mission. I trust myself more with contempt than with blood guilt. Contempt can still be used. Blood guilt just ferments.
That is the deciding line for me. I would rather let the board expose itself in daylight by taking public shots at me than expose myself as the man who weaponized grandma for applause. I hate the corporate dunk ritual because it is demeaning as hell and teaches the room exactly the wrong lesson. But it still leaves one moral wall standing that the other option burns to the dirt. I cannot be the hand that drops my own grandmother for crowd approved fun.
So I am making the call. I choose Board Dunk. I choose it because I would rather let the suits take their stupid public shot at me than let my own blood become a prop in a fundraiser carnival. If the room wants a wet body and a false smile, they can have mine. They do not get hers. Let the directors throw and let the shareholders clap. The hierarchy can show its ass in daylight. I will take the fucking water before I take family betrayal.
Grandma Dunk Tank loses because it is a motherfucking humiliation machine built on bloodline inversion. It asks me to turn care into spectacle and call that generosity. It invites the crowd to laugh at the moment loyalty gets sold for a cause. That is slower death for the family bond. That is the kind of act that keeps echoing at every table afterward no matter how many good deeds the event claims it funded.
Board Dunk is still vile. It still lets power dress itself up as play while my body takes the plunge. But the ugliness stays where it belongs, on the people throwing and the system that built the booth. I pick executive cruelty over family betrayal. I pick the tank for me, not for grandma.
That's the fucking verdict. I made the call, and if your brain still works, you know where this lands.