Tommy

Would You Rather · Episode 78

Therapist Remix

2,251 words

Get ready, Tommy the Hamburger is about to twist your motherfucking brain. You're going to get two choices, and an examination of the fucking thought process behind both. Shit's about to get detailed and complicated, so you better pay attention. All right. Here is the motherfucking dilemma. Would you rather let a therapist redesign your private coping rituals into polished little treatment products, or keep those rituals exactly as they are but perform every one of them in public parks where strangers can stare, smirk, and film you while you try not to come apart? Therapist Remix gets in first because it sounds caring. That is why it is dangerous. The room smells like fake lavender, dry paper, carpet cleaner, and the stale coffee breath of people who say healing like they invented it. There is a couch too soft to trust. There is a shelf full of workbooks with cheerful covers and dead eyes. There is a whiteboard waiting to turn my mess into bullet points. There is a therapist across from me with a kind face and a predator's patience. She wants my rituals. Not just to hear them. To improve them. To optimize them. To make them usable. That is the setup. I bring in the private little coping moves that actually keep me from biting through my own week. Maybe I pace the kitchen at three in the morning. Maybe I listen to the same ugly song until the panic breaks. Maybe I write filthy little notes on receipt paper. Maybe I line up cups in a certain order. Maybe I sit in the dark with a fan on and count my breathing like a bastard trying not to split in half. Whatever the ritual is, it came out of pain and repetition and trial. It grew in the dark. Now some therapist wants to remix it into a protocol. The body cost starts with translation. That is the first theft. I have to explain the ritual in clean language while she nods and writes it down in a way that already makes it less mine. The second it gets named properly, the second it becomes emotional regulation technique instead of my grimy little survival move, something in me starts pulling away from it. My skin gets hot. My shoulders climb. My jaw stiffens. I can feel the ritual turning into office furniture while I am still sitting there needing the original version. And the false hope on this side is real enough to tempt me. Maybe the remix makes it safer. Maybe the thing I do in private is too harsh, too weird, too brittle, too full of old damage. Maybe a professional can sand down the self hatred and leave me with something cleaner that still works. I am not too proud to admit that possibility. A lot of us need help sorting out whether our coping is actually coping or just another costume for the same wound. Fine. That part is honest. But the trap closes when the remix starts stripping the ritual for parts. The therapist wants the useful piece, the trackable piece, the repeatable piece, the part she can describe to colleagues without sounding like she lost control of the session. Suddenly my midnight pacing becomes a structured grounding walk. The ugly song becomes a curated audio intervention. The receipt paper notes become a workbook prompt. The dark room becomes a sensory reset environment. Everything gets tidied until it can be billed. That is where I start feeling violent inside. Not because help is evil. Because this kind of help can bleach the blood out of the thing until only the paperwork survives. The system cost here is filthy. Once a ritual becomes a clinical product, it starts belonging to the machine that renamed it. There are worksheets. Progress markers. App reminders. Recommended frequency. Success criteria. Some asshole in slacks can now ask whether I completed my coping sequence this week. The whole thing turns into compliance. That is the part I cannot forgive. I came in bleeding and they handed me homework with a smile. Fuck me sideways, if I wanted my private misery converted into a performance metric I would have gone back to school. The emotional cost gets uglier the longer it goes on. If the remixed version does not work, now I get to feel resistant, non compliant, difficult, attached to chaos, whatever pretty little term they use when your nervous system does not want to be rebranded. If it does work a little, I still have to live with the humiliation of knowing something raw and personal got translated into a neat professional shape before it was allowed to count. Either way I stop trusting the ritual the same way. The old one feels contaminated. The new one feels rented. The social cost is quieter but real. Friends hear therapy language creeping into my voice. I stop saying I am trying not to lose my shit and start saying I am implementing my tools. Everybody suddenly feels entitled to ask whether I used the method. That is what polished healing does. It sounds respectable enough that people think they can supervise it. The ritual stops being a private emergency valve and becomes a public good intention. People love good intentions. They can control those. Still, I get why someone would choose Therapist Remix. At least the room is contained. At least the witness is licensed. At least the damage is happening behind a door instead of out on wet grass between a dog walker and a mother pushing a stroller. Contained corruption is still corruption, but I would be lying if I said containment means nothing. Now drag yourself over to Public Ritual and feel the real humiliation machine come alive. I keep my rituals exactly as they are. No remix. No workbook varnish. No professional fingerprints. But every time I need them, I have to do them in a public park. There are joggers. Teenagers. Parents. Old men with folded arms. Kids pointing. People pretending not to stare while staring hard enough to peel paint. My private lifeline is now a scheduled show for strangers who did not earn the right to look. The setup here is cruel in a way only clean minded sadists could invent. I am not being asked to perform excellence. I am being asked to perform necessity. If I need to pace in circles and mutter to myself, I do it by the duck pond. If I need to write the same sentence forty times, I do it on a bench with somebody eating chips three feet away. If I need to rock, breathe, sing under my breath, count cracks in the pavement, kneel in the dirt, whatever the ritual is, I do it with witnesses. My coping stays mine in form, but not in atmosphere. That matters more than people think. The body cost on this side is instant. The second I know I am being watched, the ritual changes even if I swear it does not. My stomach tightens. My hands get stupid. My breathing goes wrong because now part of me is managing the audience. Shame starts wrestling the actual need. The whole point of the ritual is to lower the pressure enough that I stay in one piece. Public exposure adds new pressure right on top. Now I am not just fighting panic or rage or grief or compulsion. I am fighting spectators. And the false hope here is another slick lie. Maybe keeping the ritual unedited preserves its truth. Maybe public performance kills shame by force. Maybe if the world sees real coping, it becomes less taboo. That is the speech people give when they do not have to be the one trembling on the bench while some bored motherfucker records from twenty feet away. Visibility is not automatically dignity. Exposure is not automatically freedom. Sometimes public means contaminated. Sometimes public means the ritual never feels safe again after one bad afternoon. The social cost is savage because strangers are stupid and bored and mean in combinations that should be illegal. One person laughs. Another films. Another walks over with concern that feels like police with softer shoes. Somebody posts a clip with a caption. Somebody guesses what is wrong with me. Somebody turns a survival move into a character trait. Maybe it follows me to work. Maybe it reaches relatives. Maybe it becomes the thing I am now known for by people who never even learned my last name. That is the kind of rot exposure creates. It keeps spreading after the body settles down. Then there is the reputation cost. Public Ritual does not just risk embarrassment. It invites interpretation. Was I dangerous. Was I unstable. Was I drunk. Was I high. Was I acting. Was I trying to get attention. Was I mentally ill in the acceptable poetic way or the unacceptable social threat way. That is what the crowd starts sorting immediately. The ritual itself becomes background noise while everybody argues over what kind of freak they just saw near the fountain. I hate that just writing it out makes my chest lock. The system cost on this side is even nastier because public space always comes with unofficial enforcement. Security guards. Park staff. Cops if the wrong coward gets nervous. Wellness outreach people who talk like pamphlets. Local groups who decide my ritual is disruptive. I do not just risk shame. I risk management. My private survival move becomes an event other people think they have a right to regulate. What makes Public Ritual worse than it first sounds is how quickly it can destroy the ritual itself. The next time I need it, I remember the eyes. I remember the phones. I remember the laughter or the pity or the thin polite concern that feels even worse. Now the ritual carries humiliation inside it. Now the very thing that used to help me gets poisoned by memory. That is a slower death than professional remix. Remix steals texture. Public performance salts the ground. I can feel the difference in my body standing between these two traps. Therapist Remix makes me feel edited. Public Ritual makes me feel hunted. One side risks turning my rituals into products. The other turns them into sightings. One side is clinical theft. The other is open air desecration. So I keep pressure testing. What happens the morning after Therapist Remix? I wake up angry. I maybe hate the worksheet. I maybe ignore the app reminder. I maybe resent the therapist for trying to improve what was ugly but functional. Fine. Rotten. But the ritual still died in a closed room if it died at all. The humiliation stayed bounded. I can fight that kind of theft and maybe steal parts of myself back. What happens the morning after Public Ritual? I wake up replaying faces. I wonder who filmed. I wonder who knows. I wonder whether the bench near the trees is now ruined forever because that is where a stranger watched me breathe like a drowning animal and smirked. The ritual does not come back clean from that. It comes back wearing witnesses. Some people will still choose Public Ritual because they think public truth beats clinical control. I think that is sentimental horseshit. Truth needs conditions. Safety is one of them. If a ritual only works when the nervous system trusts the room, then the room matters as much as the act. A park full of strangers is not neutral ground. It is an attack vector with grass. Therapist Remix is still ugly. I am not romantic about the soft voiced theft of lived coping turned into institutional language. I hate how quickly healing gets repackaged into something saleable and polite. I hate being translated by people who have never had to survive in my exact shape. But if I have to pick where the violation happens, I would rather get edited in private than stripped in public. That is enough to settle it. I choose Therapist Remix. I choose the polished theft over the live humiliation. I choose the room with one licensed thief over the park full of fucking motherfuckers who would turn my worst survival moves into scenery, gossip, and clips. Public Ritual is worse because it does not just expose the coping. It contaminates it. It teaches my body that the thing keeping me alive might now arrive wearing witnesses and laughter. Here is why the other side loses. Public Ritual pretends to preserve authenticity, but what it really preserves is form while destroying shelter. It keeps the movement and murders the safety. Therapist Remix is invasive, patronizing, and stained with the smug perfume of professional care, but at least it does not hand my rituals to joggers, dog walkers, security guards, and every bored idiot with a camera and a hunger for someone else's bad hour. So stamp it down hard. I choose Therapist Remix because I would rather let one fucking therapist over translate my rituals than let a public park turn them into an open air freak show for motherfuckers who think witnessing is wisdom. Public Ritual can choke on its fake bravery and its exposure worship. That option is a slower death wearing honesty like makeup, and I am not dumb enough to call that freedom. That's the fucking verdict. I made the call, and if your brain still works, you know where this lands.