Would You Rather · Episode 81
Deepfake Sabbatical
2,139 words
Get ready, Tommy the Hamburger is about to twist your motherfucking brain. You're going to get two choices, and an examination of the fucking thought process behind both. Shit's about to get detailed and complicated, so you better pay attention.
All right. Here is the motherfucking dilemma.
Would you rather disappear for six months while a deepfake version of you handles every interview, apology, endorsement, and public smile, or keep showing up as yourself but send faulty clones to run your errands and let their screwups chew your reputation to ribbons one bad day at a time?
Deepfake Sabbatical gets in first because it sounds restful. That is exactly why I do not trust it. The room smells like hot plastic, stale coffee, metal dust, and the weird cold breath of machines that think they are smarter than grief. There are monitors stacked on folding tables. There are ring lights pointed at an empty chair. There is a camera rig waiting to capture every angle of my face so some technical grave robber can build a cleaner version of me than I have ever been on my own best day. The whole place feels like a morgue for personality.
That is the setup. I vanish. I go dark. Maybe I hide in a hotel room. Maybe I sit in some rental house eating garbage and staring at curtains while my digital twin walks through the world on my behalf. It does the interviews. It shakes the hands. It sells the brand. It explains the opinions. It smiles at the charity event. It laughs on cue. It apologizes with perfect lighting. Meanwhile I am alive somewhere, but my public body is now software wearing my mouth.
The body cost starts with separation. I am still breathing, but the version of me people interact with is a machine. That should make any sane person feel nauseous. The stomach knows when the self has been split. I would wake up every morning with that electric wrongness in my chest, knowing some fake copy already said things in my voice before I had coffee. Maybe it praised a sponsor I hate. Maybe it softened a sentence I would have sharpened. Maybe it made me look wiser, calmer, kinder, more manageable. That last part is what really makes my skin crawl. A fake version of me that behaves better than I do becomes an indictment.
And the false hope here is seductive as hell. Maybe I need the break. Maybe six months off from appearances lets me breathe. Maybe the deepfake keeps the bills paid while I crawl out from under whatever has been grinding me into powder. There is logic there. Real logic. Plenty of people would trade authenticity for a little rest if the rent still clears and the audience stays warm. I am not too proud to admit that. Exhaustion can make monstrous compromises look practical.
But the trap closes the second the deepfake starts doing the job well. If the fake me handles interviews smoothly, then the world learns it does not need my live nerves, my weird pauses, my ugly edges, my surprise, my temper, my human timing. It just needs the brand shape. That is the deep rot in this option. The machine does not have to beat me. It just has to prove I am inefficient. Once that happens, every future appearance is haunted by the question of whether the synthetic version would have done it cleaner.
The system cost is savage. A deepfake sabbatical does not just buy me time off. It trains the industry to prefer replicas. Sponsors love predictability. Studios love compliance. Publicists love statements that never wobble. Once my fake can deliver those things, real me becomes a risk factor, a difficult variable, a loud animal the room no longer has to tolerate. That should scare anybody who still thinks being imperfect in public is a human right.
The emotional cost is worse because I would have to watch my own replacement grow better liked than me. Fans quote lines I never said. Clips go viral from moments I never lived. People talk about how rested I look, how thoughtful I sound, how much I have matured, and the whole time I know that version of me was assembled by technicians who probably call authenticity friction in meetings. Fuck me sideways, that is the kind of humiliation that gets in the bones.
Then there is the reputation cost, which comes in two rotten flavors. If the deepfake is too perfect, people trust the fake more than the man. If it glitches, then I get blamed for every uncanny smile, every stiff gesture, every bad statement, every weird tone. Either way I pay. Best case, my identity gets laundered. Worst case, it gets corrupted. There is no clean win once your face becomes a file format.
Still, I understand why somebody would choose it. At least the public mess stays centralized. At least the errors, if they come, are coming from one controlled fake instead of a whole swarm of idiot copies wandering the city in my shape. Centralized corruption has a certain ugly appeal. I can admit that.
Now drag yourself over to Errand Clones and feel a different kind of rot. I stay present. I keep doing my real work. I keep talking in my own voice. Fine. But every petty task gets handed to a faulty clone of me. Groceries. Dry cleaning. Mail runs. Coffee pickups. Pharmacy stops. Hardware store trips. Gas station trash. One little bastard spills soup on somebody's shoes. Another mouths off to a cashier. Another forgets the dog in the car for three minutes too long. Another gets lost and starts explaining itself badly on a stranger's porch. My face is attached to all of it.
That is the setup here. The clones are recognizably me but wrong in the little ways that matter. The smile is late. The eyes are flat. The patience is thinner. The instinct for embarrassment is weaker. They can pass at a glance, fail up close, and cause enough damage in between to ruin my week. The city fills up with small bad versions of Tommy handling all the tiny places where reputation usually lives quietly. That is the filthy genius of this option. Not one grand disaster. A thousand petty cuts.
The body cost on this side is constant dread. Every phone buzz becomes a possible clip. Every message from a friend could be did one of your clones just scream at a parking kiosk. I would start scanning my own life like a crime scene before the crimes even finished happening. The pulse never settles because the damage can occur anywhere. Not in a press conference. Not on a stage. In a laundromat. At a deli. In line at the bank. In all the places where people build their private opinion of whether you are an asshole.
And the false hope here is obvious too. Maybe the clones only ruin the small stuff. Maybe the big work stays mine and the city learns to laugh off the copies. Maybe a little public chaos is better than full digital replacement. There is truth in that. The core self does stay active. The real work still belongs to me. The public voice is still live. That matters a lot more than I want it to. But the damage does not stay small for long when your face keeps showing up attached to weird little failures people can record in vertical video and send to each other over breakfast.
The social cost is brutal because everyday reputation is built out of errands. The barista remembers. The pharmacist remembers. The neighbor remembers. The security guard remembers. One clone acts like a cheap prick at the grocery store and suddenly that story outruns anything noble I said into a microphone all month. People trust the mundane more than the official. They think the real truth of a person comes out when he is tired and buying batteries. So if my clones keep blowing those moments, my whole name starts smelling cheap.
The emotional cost is ugly because each clone failure is small enough to be deniable and large enough to sting. It is not one clean scandal I can address. It is a fog of shabby little humiliations. Did I really shove past somebody at the post office. Did I really flirt with that hostess like a malfunctioning creep. Did I really knock over the flowers and walk away. I know I did not. But the footage says Tommy did. That kind of friction wears a person down. You spend half your life defending events you never lived.
The reputation cost might even be worse than the direct cost, because clones attack consistency. If people cannot trust which Tommy they are looking at during ordinary life, then every normal encounter gets a little infected. The audience starts wondering whether I am rude by default and polished only on camera. That suspicion can hollow out a public life slower than any big scandal.
What makes Errand Clones especially rotten is how tempting it becomes to stop fixing the fallout. After the twentieth explanation, after the fiftieth apology, after the hundredth little cleanup, I might start going numb. That numbness is its own trap. I could become careless about my own name out of pure fatigue. That is how a man loses the instinct to protect himself. Not through one collapse. Through repetition.
I can feel the difference in my body standing between these two traps. Deepfake Sabbatical makes me feel erased. Errand Clones makes me feel contaminated. One side steals the center. The other side stains the edges until the center starts losing credibility anyway. One is replacement. The other is infestation.
So I keep pressure testing. What happens the morning after Deepfake Sabbatical? I wake up and check what fake me said while I slept. Maybe it was harmless. Maybe it was polished. Maybe it was better than me, which is the worst part. Every day becomes proof that my absence can be monetized more efficiently than my presence. That is soul damage, not just brand damage.
What happens the morning after Errand Clones? I wake up and deal with a list of stupid little fires. Refund this. Apologize there. Explain that the idiot at the bakery was one of the copies. Maybe I am angry. Maybe embarrassed. Maybe exhausted. But I am still the live source. I am still the one speaking in first person. The damage is real, but the center still breathes.
Some people will still choose Deepfake Sabbatical because they think the big stage matters more than the grocery store. I think that is backward. If I give away the stage itself, I have already lost something I might never get back. Better a hundred shabby little clone incidents than a world that learns it can fully replace my public self and barely miss a beat.
Errand Clones is still ugly. I am not romantic about my face being used by a herd of faulty halfwits to collect small resentments across town. It would be draining. It would be humiliating. It would turn every mundane day into a possible reputation leak. But if I have to choose which poison leaves the self more intact, I would rather spend six months cleaning up clone mess than spend six months watching a synthetic version of me become the preferred edition.
That is enough to settle it.
I choose Errand Clones. I choose the swarm of stupid public mixups over the polished digital replacement. I choose being embarrassed by faulty copies over letting a fucking deepfake teach the whole world that Tommy is just a format any motherfucker with enough processors can fill. Deepfake Sabbatical is worse because it does not just tarnish the name. It severs the name from the living body and asks me to call that rest.
Here is why the other side loses. Deepfake Sabbatical pretends to offer relief, but what it really offers is professionalized erasure with nice lighting and better posture. Errand Clones can rot the reputation around the edges, yes, but the center still belongs to me. The real voice still speaks. The real face still has to answer. Deepfake Sabbatical salts the core. That is the slower death.
So stamp it down hard. I choose Errand Clones because I would rather spend half a year apologizing for idiot copies at the post office than let a fucking synthetic Tommy become the smoother, safer version that sponsors and motherfuckers in headsets decide they prefer forever. Deepfake Sabbatical can choke on its rest, its optimization, and its fake humanity.
That's the fucking verdict. I made the call, and if your brain still works, you know where this lands.