Tommy

Would You Rather · Episode 93

Fan Reality Jury

2,205 words

Get ready, Tommy the Hamburger is about to twist your motherfucking brain. You're going to get two choices, and an examination of the fucking thought process behind both. Shit's about to get detailed and complicated, so you better pay attention. All right. Here is the motherfucking dilemma. Would you rather let a fan jury vote on every major decision in your life, or keep control of your own choices but inherit your audience's worst unsolved problems and fix them like they are yours? This fucking studio smells like overheated lights, cheap carpet glue, and stress sweat, and the motherfuckers behind the voting desk keep smiling like they are offering community instead of a public execution. The room is built like a courtroom for people who think attention is wisdom. A giant screen hangs over the set showing live vote totals. Green bars. Red bars. Little arrows climbing every time some stranger decides he knows what I should do with my body, my money, my work, or my bed. Off to the side there is a wall of printed letters and digital messages from viewers. Divorce trouble. Medical debt. Brother in jail. Daughter won't speak to me. Rent is late. My teeth hurt and I keep ignoring it. I can feel the whole place leaning in both directions at once. One side wants to own me. The other wants to empty itself into me. Here is the split clean enough for a knife. Option one means every major decision goes to the fan jury. Relationships. Career moves. Money choices. Health choices. Moving. Staying. Signing. Leaving. If the jury says do it, I do it. If the jury says don't, I don't. Option two means I keep my freedom to decide my own life, but I inherit the audience's ugliest unresolved problems as formal obligations. Their debts become my debts to settle. Their family wreckage becomes my business to sort out. Their legal messes, their illnesses, their collapsing lives all get stacked onto my shoulders while I still try to carry my own. The fan jury is the cleaner looking trap, which is why idiots would call it beautiful. They hear the word community and start drooling. They hear participation and think love. They imagine a crowd lifting you with shared wisdom. What it really is is surrender to people who do not pay the cost of being wrong. That is the part that makes me furious. If they vote for me to take a stupid deal and it ruins a year of my life, they do not absorb the year. If they vote for me to stay with the wrong person because the chemistry looks good on camera, they do not sleep beside the rot. If they vote for me to risk my health because struggle inspires them, they do not carry the bill in the meat of their own body. Crowds love danger when somebody else has to bleed for it. That is the oldest trick in the species. They call it bold when the fall is not theirs. They call it romantic when the wreckage will not be in their kitchen. That is exactly what a fan jury would become. A giant machine that converts boredom into my consequences. They would tell themselves they care. Some of them would even mean it. Does not matter. Care without cost is still just opinion wearing perfume. I know what would happen to me under that system because I know what crowds do to a man who starts listening too hard. First comes the self doubt. Not even dramatic self doubt. Petty little erosion. You catch yourself before making the move you already know is right because you can hear the jury noise in the back of your skull. Maybe they would hate this. Maybe this does not poll well. Maybe I should soften it. Maybe I should delay it. Maybe I should be who they seem to want right now. That is how a spine gets turned into customer service. Then the body follows. You stop sleeping right because every choice feels watched before it is made. Your stomach gets mean. Meals start tasting like pregame rituals for judgment. You wake up already bracing for what the tally board might tell you to do with your own damn afternoon. The jury does not even need to yell. Just the existence of the vote is enough to make your pulse act like you are permanently one room away from being sentenced. And there is a false hope in it that makes the trap stronger. The false hope says maybe the crowd knows me better than I know myself. Maybe they see patterns I miss. Maybe surrendering choice is freedom from the burden of getting life wrong. That story is catnip for exhausted people. When you are tired enough, control starts to feel heavy. You think maybe letting ten thousand strangers decide could finally quiet the noise. No. It does not quiet the noise. It multiplies it and hands you a bill. Now the other side. Borrowed problems. On paper it sounds noble. That is why it is disgusting. Keep your agency, Tommy. Keep your choices. Just absorb the audience's heaviest unresolved shit and prove you care by fixing it. That sounds almost saintly if you are half asleep. What it actually means is waking up every day inside an avalanche that was already moving before your name got attached to it. Somebody's mother is dying. Somebody's son cannot stop gambling. Somebody lost the house. Somebody is drowning in appeals paperwork. Somebody cannot get out of bed. Somebody blew a marriage apart and now wants absolution dressed up as guidance. If those become mine, then my life stops being a life and becomes a landfill with a microphone. The world would praise it at first because the world always praises a man who looks willing to disappear for other people. That praise is filth. It is the praise people give when they are glad the burden moved off their own chest. And the burden does not come in neat heroic chunks. It comes in swarms. Forms. Phone calls. Tears. Missed payments. Medication schedules. Relapses. Lies from scared people who need help badly enough to start editing the truth. You cannot absorb that much wreckage without changing shape. That is the part the empathy salesmen always hide. They act like compassion expands a person forever. No. Past a certain point it hollows him out. If I adopt enough borrowed problems, then every morning starts with somebody else's emergency already sitting on my throat. My own bills wait. My own body waits. My own work waits. My own relationships wait while I go crawling through somebody else's burning ceiling. Do that long enough and you do not become generous. You become resentful and ashamed of the resentment. That is a brutal combination. There is body cost here too, and it is ugly in a slower way than the jury. The jury spikes your nerves. Borrowed problems grind your organs down like sand in a gearbox. Your shoulders stay high because there is always one more crisis waiting in the stack. Your phone becomes a hate object. Every buzz could be another catastrophe. Every quiet moment curdles because you know somebody out there is still drowning while you are eating toast like a selfish bastard. You start hating the people you are trying to help because they keep arriving, then you hate yourself for hating them, and then you keep helping because guilt is the cheapest fuel in the world. The false hope on this side is even more poisonous. It says maybe if I carry enough of everybody else's suffering, my own life will feel justified. Maybe being useful at that scale means I finally earn the right to take up space. Maybe if I solve enough of the audience's pain, I do not have to sit with the ordinary private pain in my own chest. That is martyr brain. That is the sickness that turns one decent impulse into a full time religion of self deletion. So which trap kills slower? That is the real question. The jury steals command. Borrowed problems steal capacity. The jury turns me into a puppet. Borrowed problems turn me into a dump truck. I hate both. But one of them still leaves the center of my life in my own hands. That matters more than people like to admit. If my hands are still on the wheel, even under a mountain of borrowed misery, I can still set limits. I can still decide which fires get water and which ones get truth instead. A jury does not leave room for that. A jury makes my own judgment ornamental. And I do not trust crowds with intimacy. I trust them even less with long term consequence. A crowd votes with appetite. A single person might tell me to do the cruel sensible thing because he thinks it is right. Ten thousand people together start voting for spectacle without even noticing the switch. They will call it growth when what they mean is they want to see if I crack prettier this way. That is not community. That is legalized heckling with a moral costume on. Borrowed problems at least have a built in honesty. There is no illusion there once the stack gets high enough. It hurts because human lives hurt. It weighs a ton because the world is badly run and people are trapped under machinery they never built. I could face that and still tell the truth. I could say I cannot fix all of this. I could say your debt is now on my desk but the lesson is not that I am a hero. The lesson is that the system that produced your debt deserves gasoline. I could say your marriage is in my inbox now but I am not pretending to be your savior, only the bastard forced to read the pattern clearly and say the sentence nobody wants. That matters. A jury would make me dishonest before breakfast. Borrowed problems would make me tired, angry, overextended, maybe half broken, but I could still speak from my own center. I could still tell a viewer no. I could still say this one gets money, this one gets a lawyer, this one gets a train ticket, this one gets a hard truth and no more of my time. The crowd would hate that. Good. At least the hate would be for a choice I made. My body has already answered anyway. When I picture the fan jury owning my decisions, I feel my chest cave in. I feel my posture go small. I feel that ugly little pre obedience people develop when they have to guess what the room wants before they move. When I picture inheriting the audience's worst problems, I feel dread and fatigue, sure, but I also feel anger. Anger is workable. Anger still has muscles in it. Collapse does not. Fuck me sideways, I am not giving the wheel to a room full of spectators just because they clap loud enough to call it love. I would rather drown in other people's emergencies and keep my own hand on the lock than live one day by referendum and call it connection. If I am going to be ruined, I want to be ruined by carrying too much reality, not by becoming an interactive toy for strangers with polling rights. So I choose borrowed problems. I choose the crushing inbox, the impossible stack, the nights where somebody else's catastrophe interrupts my dinner, the fury that comes with seeing how many lives are being chewed by systems built to fail them. I choose that over the fan jury because even under that load I remain the one deciding what gets done, what gets refused, what gets named honestly, and what gets burned down on principle. I would rather be overwhelmed and still autonomous than popular and domesticated. The losing side is the fan reality jury, and it loses because it is a humiliation machine disguised as participation. It tells you that surrendering your life to the crowd is humble when really it is just a cleaner way to erase yourself. It hands ownership of your choices to people who will never pay the blood cost of being wrong, then dares you to call that wisdom. That is not democracy. That is cowardice spread across enough bodies to look normal. Borrowed problems wins because the pain stays in the realm of actual human need instead of public appetite. It is brutal. It is unsustainable forever. It would grind me raw if I did it long enough. Fine. At least it would still be me grinding against something real. I would rather carry a thousand ugly emergencies and bark my way through the pile than let a voting wall tell me who to date, where to go, what to sign, or how to waste my one life for the crowd. Keep the burden if you must. Never hand over the wheel. That's the fucking verdict. I made the call, and if your brain still works, you know where this lands.