Tommy

Would You Rather · Episode 96

Fan Dream Writers

1,880 words

Get ready, Tommy the Hamburger is about to twist your motherfucking brain. You're going to get two choices, and an examination of the fucking thought process behind both. Shit's about to get detailed and complicated, so you better pay attention. All right. Here is the motherfucking dilemma. Would you rather let fans write your dreams through sleep tech, or let a nightmare alert system monitor your sleep and wake you up every time it decides you are too scared? This fucking sleep lab smells like warm plastic, old sheets, and that sour chemical slime they smear on your scalp when machines want to pretend they understand the brain, and the motherfuckers selling both options keep smiling like rest is something they invented. The room is split into two kinds of violation. On one side there is a padded recliner under a dome of projection glass, all wired up to let outsiders feed prompts into whatever I dream. On the wall behind it a screen scrolls fan submissions like menu items. Dream about fame. Dream about revenge. Dream about your ex apologizing. Dream about fighting God in a parking lot. Dream about drowning in barbecue sauce. Stupid. Petty. Creepy. On the other side there is a hospital style bed under sensors that watch pulse, sweat, eye movement, breathing, and muscle tension. If the software decides the dream has crossed the fear line, alarms fire and the bed yanks you out of sleep. Here is the split clean enough for a knife. Fan dream writers means strangers vote on what enters my sleep. They do not control every detail, but they set the scene and send it down into the dark where my mind is supposed to be doing private work. Nightmare alerts mean the dreams stay mine, but a monitoring system watches for terror and interrupts the moment it thinks my own unconscious has become too rough to tolerate. One option crowdsources the content of my sleep. The other polices it. The fan writing side is the uglier seduction because it pretends to be intimacy. That is always how people get tricked into letting strangers too close. They call it sharing. They call it connection. They say what could be more honest than letting the audience into your dreams. That idea can go get buried. Dreams are not bonus footage. Dreams are where your mind drags the body's secrets into costumes and makes them dance until something real gets processed. Shame goes in there. Fear goes in there. Desire, grief, humiliation, lust, dread, old voices, unfinished fights, all of it goes in there and does whatever twisted work it has to do. If I hand that room over to fans, the first thing that dies is privacy. Not waking privacy. Core privacy. The ugly deep kind. Even if the prompts start silly, the mechanism itself teaches the mind that sleep is now public land. People get curious. Curiosity gets mean. Mean gets invasive. Pretty soon it is no longer dream about flying or dream about being rich. It becomes dream about the father you never forgave. Dream about the one who left. Dream about the body you hate. Dream about the wound you only show sideways. That is what crowds do. They start with novelty and end with dissection. And the body would feel it. I know that for a fact. Sleep would stop feeling like surrender and start feeling like exposure. You lie down already defensive. Your jaw stays half tight. Your pulse never fully drops because some part of you knows the night now has an audience. Then when the dream starts, even if it is absurd, the violation has already happened. Somebody got to knock on the door first. Somebody got to set the weather in the room where your mind keeps its rawest mess. That alone is enough to make rest go bad. There is false hope in it too, which makes it a stronger trap. The false hope says maybe outside people can give you dreams your own mind would never think to make. Maybe they can unlock something. Maybe creative crowdsourced sleep makes you deeper, funnier, wiser, more honest. No. It makes you contaminated. The dream stops being a private processing chamber and becomes an assignment. Once that happens, you stop sleeping into truth and start sleeping into performance. Now the other side. Nightmare alerts. This one sounds more caring at first, which is why I distrust it even harder. The pitch is simple. Let the dream happen until it gets dangerous, then the system rescues you. Heart rate spikes, you wake. Breathing goes ragged, you wake. Panic signs cross the line, you wake. No plunging too deep. No lingering in fear long enough to drown. Just a nice polite interruption every time your sleeping mind starts saying something too ugly in a voice the software can measure. That is disgusting in a softer way. It assumes terror has no use. It assumes fear is only a defect state and not sometimes the exact road the mind has to walk to finish a piece of buried work. I am not saying nightmares are pleasant. They are awful. You wake with your heart trying to punch through your ribs and the room looks wrong for ten seconds. But that does not mean they are empty. Sometimes a nightmare is the brain dragging you to a truth you duck all day with jokes and work and noise. If a machine keeps waking me at the edge of every real nightmare, it does not save me. It just teaches my mind that the bad thing never has to complete itself. That is not protection. That is psychological edging by a compliance department. The fear remains. The image remains. The unfinished charge remains. All that changes is I lose the chance to go through it fully and come out the other side. There is body cost here too, and it would stack up fast. Broken sleep is a slow knife. You never quite get down deep enough. The machine rips you out just as the body drops its guard. Then morning arrives and your muscles feel borrowed, your eyes ache, your temper gets weird, and all day you carry the residue of dreams you were not allowed to finish. Enough nights like that and you become one of those haunted bastards walking around half awake, half defended, angry at everyone and not fully sure why. And the social cost would be rotten too. People would start asking whether I seem better rested, safer, more stable, like the interruptions are some kind of improvement. That is the insult hidden inside all supervised suffering. The outside world sees fewer visible flames and assumes the house must be healthier. Meanwhile I am walking around full of half processed terror, snapping at breakfast, losing words mid sentence, and feeling the unfinished nightmare still scratching at the back wall of my skull. The false hope here says maybe you can remove suffering without paying for it. Maybe if fear gets intercepted early enough, then healing still happens cleanly. That is another elegant lie. No. If the nightmare matters, then breaking it apart every time just leaves the poison in suspension. You do not become safer. You become interrupted. So which violation is worse? Fan dream writers steal ownership. Nightmare alerts steal completion. One turns the night into public property. The other turns the night into a monitored hallway with exit signs every ten feet. I hate both. But one still leaves the actual material of the dream mine. That matters. If the system wakes me too early, the dream was still born in my blood. If fans plant the seed, then even the raw material starts carrying other people's fingerprints. That is the part I cannot stomach. My waking life is already noisy enough with opinion. I will not let strangers colonize the one place where the mind is supposed to speak in its own broken animal dialect. Let a machine interrupt me if it must. I can fight interruption. I can take the monitors off. I can ignore the warnings. I can rip the wires loose if I have to. But if I start normalizing fan access to my dreams, then I am the idiot who opened the gate and called invasion participation. My body already knows which one disgusts me more. When I look at the fan prompt wall, I feel revulsion. Not fear first. Revulsion. The kind that makes the back of your neck tighten because something private is being discussed by people who did not earn entry. When I look at the nightmare alert bed, I feel anger. Good. Anger can still work. Anger can yank wires out. Anger can throw the monitor through the glass. Revulsion tells me the boundary itself has been insulted. And there is another hard truth. Fans are not gentle with access. Even the sweet ones get weird once you tell them the door is open. They start believing their affection entitles them to texture. Then texture becomes ownership. Then ownership becomes pressure. Write us a dream about this. Dream the version where you forgive that. Dream the version where you finally admit that. Dream our theory. Dream our need. Dream our fantasy of you. No. Absolutely not. That road ends with a man who cannot tell whether his own sleep still belongs to him. Fuck me sideways, nightmares are mine. Even the ugly ones. Especially the ugly ones. I would rather let some twitchy machine drag me out of sleep at the worst possible second and hate it for the rest of my life than invite the audience into the wet dark workshop where my brain keeps the unfinished monsters. If fear is going to interrupt me, let it at least be my fear first. So I choose nightmare alerts. I choose the broken sleep, the rude wakeups, the rage at being yanked out of the deep end, the frustration of unfinished terror, the very real risk that I end up exhausted and half feral from the interruptions. I choose that because it still leaves the dream itself as mine before the system panics. The nightmare may get cut off, but it is born from my own mind, not injected by a crowd with dirty curiosity and time to kill. The losing side is fan dream writers, and it loses because it is a humiliation machine disguised as intimacy. It turns the last private room in the human body into a suggestion box for strangers, then acts like vulnerability means letting other people spray paint your unconscious. That is not connection. That is trespassing with a smile. Nightmare alerts win because the harm stays secondary. They are invasive, stupid, exhausting, and paternal in all the worst ways. Fine. At least they are reacting to my own material instead of planting theirs. I would rather wake up furious a hundred times than fall asleep once knowing some grinning motherfucker got to vote on what my brain has to drag through the dark. Keep the nightmares ugly if you must. Never let the crowd into your sleep. That's the fucking verdict. I made the call, and if your brain still works, you know where this lands.