Tommy

Would You Rather · Episode 98

Sim Audit

1,852 words

Get ready, Tommy the Hamburger is about to twist your motherfucking brain. You're going to get two choices, and an examination of the fucking thought process behind both. Shit's about to get detailed and complicated, so you better pay attention. All right. Here is the motherfucking dilemma. Would you rather undergo a simulation audit to prove reality is real, or file an emotional tax form that itemizes every feeling you had this year like it owes the government paperwork? This fucking office smells like printer toner, hot circuitry, and nervous spit, and the motherfuckers running the place keep talking like existence and grief are both things a decent form can tidy up. The room is split into two bureaucratic nightmares. On the left there is an audit station with scanners, interview lights, memory tests, and a long steel chair aimed at a wall of questions. Did your childhood contain rendering errors? Have you observed anyone repeating behavior with nonhuman precision? Does gravity ever feel too convenient when nobody is looking? On the right there is a tax desk with binders, folders, and a software screen full of emotional categories. Rage. Grief. Awe. Lust. Panic. Relief. Shame. Hope. Each one has boxes for duration, severity, and supporting notes like sorrow is a mileage deduction. Here is the split in plain language. The simulation audit means I sit down and let a system test whether this reality is authentic or some artificial setup dressed up as a life. It interviews my memories. It measures anomalies. It treats existence like a suspicious expense report. The emotional tax form means I keep reality unquestioned, but every major feeling I had this year gets logged, classified, and reported with enough detail to satisfy a bureaucrat who thinks tears are a line item. The sim audit is the cleaner looking trap because it flatters your fear. Everybody has had the thought at least once. Maybe this is fake. Maybe these people are too repetitive. Maybe the day looped weird. Maybe the coincidence came in too neat. Maybe the room feels rendered instead of built. Once that fear gets stroked, a certain kind of bastard starts craving proof. That is how the audit hooks you. It tells you maybe certainty is available if you just submit to enough tests. That sounds tempting until you think for five seconds. Any proof it gives me still happens inside the reality being questioned. That means the result is infected before it leaves the room. If the audit says real, the fake world could say that just as easily. If the audit says unclear, then all I bought was an official panic attack. If it says likely simulated, then congratulations, now I have a stamped document for a crisis no one can fix. That is not truth. That is paranoia in a tie. And the body cost would be immediate. Once you start answering those questions seriously, your nervous system gets ugly. You begin combing your own history for glitches. That teacher who always said the same thing. That neighbor with the blank stare. That accident with the impossible timing. That week you can barely remember. The mind becomes a rat chewing wires inside its own walls. Sleep goes bad. Food tastes provisional. Conversations start sounding rehearsed. You stop living in the room and start inspecting it for seams. There is a false hope inside the audit too, which is what makes it dangerous. It says maybe if reality is confirmed, all your fear settles down. Or maybe if reality is exposed as fake, then the pain becomes easier to dismiss because it was only code. Both versions are lies. If life is real, the fear does not vanish. If life is fake, the pain does not magically stop hurting. The body still sweats. The chest still caves when bad news arrives. A simulated punch still breaks a simulated nose. I do not care how elegant the philosophy looks. Suffering still cashes out in flesh. Now the other side. Emotional tax forms. This one sounds absurd enough that people might laugh first, and that is exactly why it is nasty. Anything that ridiculous can sneak closer before you slap it. The idea is simple. At the end of the year I report my emotional activity like a little accountant of the soul. How many hours of grief. How much joy connected to work. How much rage tied to family. Did panic produce material benefit. Did love create measurable loss. Break it down. Average it out. Attach notes if the intensity exceeded standard thresholds. That is revolting for reasons a decent person should not need explained. Feelings are not clean even when they are honest. Grief leaks into hunger. Shame sneaks into lust. Joy gets tangled with guilt. Love gets mixed with resentment and fear so thoroughly you can barely tell which strand is steering. The form wants category. Life gives overlap. The form wants countable units. Life gives weather fronts. The form wants compliance. Life gives spill. And the body cost would be slow and evil. Once you know every feeling has to be filed, you stop feeling cleanly. You start bookkeeping while the thing is still happening. Part of your mind stays outside the experience with a clipboard. How long has this sadness lasted? Does this qualify as acute or sustained? If I laugh right now, is it recreational or restorative? That split poisons the moment before it fully arrives. You do not cry straight through anymore because some bureaucratic worm in your skull is already estimating duration. That is what makes this one such a sick trap. It takes the messiest part of being alive and trains you to stand outside it counting. People will call that self awareness. No. It is emotional taxidermy. It turns living feeling into a dead display pinned under labels after the beating stops. There is false hope here too. The false hope says maybe if I track every feeling carefully enough, I finally understand myself. Maybe the forms reveal a pattern. Maybe the categories expose where the damage lives. Maybe quantified emotion becomes manageable emotion. That is another bureaucratic fairy tale. The big feelings in life do not become truer because they fit boxes. They become smaller. Meaner. Safer for institutions. A system that can categorize your grief can eventually tell you which grief is allowed. Then it can tell you which joy looks excessive, which anger needs review, and which fear failed the approved wording. So which trap destroys me slower? The simulation audit corrupts my relationship to reality. The emotional tax form corrupts my relationship to feeling. One makes the world suspect. The other makes the self suspect. I hate both. But one still leaves me the right to feel without accounting while the other directly infects every future emotion with paperwork. That difference matters more than people think. If I walk out of the sim audit wrecked, at least I can still cry whole. I can still rage whole. I can still laugh without mentally preparing a report about why the laugh happened and whether the laugh counts as taxable uplift. The audit may destabilize the world around me, but the tax form destabilizes the bloodstream. It turns every emotion into pre compliance material. I would rather mistrust the walls than mistrust the tears while they are still wet. And there is another practical truth. A reality audit does not have to get my cooperation forever. I can take the damn test, hear the result, and then tell the result to go choke. Emotional forms are worse because they breed. Once a system starts demanding categories for the soul, it never stops. Quarterly filing. Revised estimates. Amended grief. Supplemental rage. Appeal denied because your documented numbness lacked enough supporting context. That is hell built out of office furniture. There is a work cost in that too. Imagine trying to make anything honest while some piece of your brain is wondering whether the feeling behind it has already been filed wrong. Art would curdle. Love would curdle. Even a simple apology would come out stiff because the room would no longer belong to the feeling itself. It would belong to the record of the feeling, and records always rot faster than the thing they claim to preserve. There is a social cost hidden in that form too. People around you would start talking its language back at you. Friends would ask whether your sadness has been fully processed and reported. A partner would wonder if your love for them falls in the right bracket. Some asshole at work would tell you your anger looked undeclared. Once the filing system exists, every vulture in your life gets a way to act like access is care. That is how institutions spread. First they ask for paperwork. Then the language of the paperwork crawls into every room until even comfort starts sounding like compliance. My body already knows which one disgusts me more. When I picture the simulation audit, I feel dread and irritation. That is survivable. When I picture filling out line items for heartbreak and fear, I feel something meaner. I feel the exact kind of contempt that rises when a system gets too close to something sacred and stupidly believes proximity equals ownership. It does not own my joy. It does not own my dread. It does not get to number them and call that insight. Fuck me sideways, I will sit in a steel chair and let some overeducated bastard ask whether my world is rendered before I let a clerk weigh my grief like produce. At least the audit insults the world from the outside. The tax form insults the inside directly. It asks me to betray the shape of a feeling while I am still trying to survive it. So I choose the simulation audit. I choose the bad questions, the suspicious lights, the memory tests, the risk that I walk out more unsettled than I walked in. I choose that because even if the audit shakes my faith in reality, it still leaves my feelings unfiled and wild. I can live with cosmic uncertainty better than I can live with itemized sorrow. The losing side is the emotional tax form, and it loses because it is a humiliation machine disguised as reflection. It pretends to honor feeling by documenting it, but what it really does is force emotion to stand still for inspection until all the heat runs out of it. That is not understanding. That is confiscation. Simulation audit wins because the damage stays philosophical instead of entering every heartbeat. It is invasive, stupid, and likely useless. Fine. At least it does not make me count my own fear in taxable units. I would rather let some machine question whether the walls are real than spend one year turning my private grief into deductible paperwork for bureaucratic vampires. Let reality stay uncertain if it must. Never file your soul. That's the fucking verdict. I made the call, and if your brain still works, you know where this lands.