Tommy

Would You Rather · Episode 23

Matriarch Reality Show

2,514 words

Get ready, Tommy the Hamburger is about to twist your motherfucking brain. You're going to get two choices, and an examination of the fucking thought process behind both. Shit's about to get detailed and complicated, so you better pay attention. All right. Here is the motherfucking dilemma. Would you rather turn Sunday dinner into a fucking reality show that airs every ugly secret this family ever tried to lacquer over, or sign an N D A for the matriarch and become a motherfucker ghost every time the truth tries to crawl out of your mouth? I am standing in the dining room where half my personality got built out of swallowed rage and cheap politeness, with the smell of overcooked onions trapped in old money. The room smells like hot gravy and furniture polish, with candle smoke sitting over old perfume and cold roast fat under the sour edge of panic trapped in expensive fabric. The chandelier is too bright. The chairs are too stiff. The lawyer has set a neat black folder beside my plate like it belongs next to the bread basket. At the far end of the table the matriarch is sitting straight backed in pearls and contempt, looking at me the same way rich old families look at fire. Useful at a distance. Unacceptable up close. Fuck me sideways, one choice makes the whole bloodline public property. The other choice makes me shut up forever and call that dignity. The worst part is that everybody in this room already knows what the actual family business is. It is not shipping or banking. It is not land deals or hospitality either, no matter what polished lie gets printed on the holiday card. The real business is pressure. It lives at dinner and in the hallway, then in the little pauses after somebody says something almost honest and the room waits to see if the matriarch will kill it with a look. That is what gets inherited here. Not love. Not wisdom. Pressure with silverware. If I choose the reality show, every Sunday turns into a public feeding. Cameras go in the corners and mics get tucked under the flowers. Cousins pretend they forgot the crew is there while secretly leaning into their best angle. The old woman at the head of the table smiles like she invented composure while producers beg everybody to answer one more ugly question before dessert. If I choose the N D A, then I sign away my right to describe what this family actually does to people, and every future lie told about me gets to walk around in daylight while I sit there gagged by paper and inheritance math. The reality show side has a pull to it. I am not too proud to admit that. There is a rotten little thrill in imagining the family machine finally having to operate under direct light. No more whispered corrections after the fact. No more cousins pretending they did not hear what was said. No more matriarch editing history in real time because she outranks everyone else's memory. A camera would catch the hand gestures and the little cruelties. It would catch the timing too, along with the way she asks a question that is really a knife with a napkin over it. A show would not fix the family, but it would stop the family from pretending the poison has no smell. That is the bait, and it is good bait. If you grew up with power doing its filth in private, exposure starts sounding like salvation. You think maybe evidence will save you. Maybe a clip will do what years of private protest could not do. Maybe the audience will finally hear the tone under the words and understand why a harmless little comment about career choices or dating history can make your whole back lock up. Then maybe the old bastard finally has to share a room with consequences. But reality television is not exposure in some pure noble sense. It is a carnival knife wearing mascara. The second cameras enter the room, the whole event mutates. Dinner stops being dinner. It becomes a hunt for usable damage. Every person at the table starts making tiny decisions about how they want to look once the episode is cut. The cousin who usually hides goes sharp because screen time makes him brave. The aunt who never says anything direct starts dropping poison in prettier sentences because she knows a confessional booth is waiting down the hall. Even I would change. Anybody would. You start hearing yourself while you are still talking. You start noticing which silence lands. You stop having one experience and start having two. The moment itself, then the version of the moment that will survive after editors get their wet little hands on it. The body cost would be filthy. Dinner is already a stress ritual in this house. Add lights and you get a pressure cooker with makeup on. The neck gets hot and the mouth dries out, then the food turns to cardboard because chewing feels stupid while your family is trying to kill each other politely in front of three lenses and a producer mouthing keep going from behind a ficus. I know exactly what would happen to me. My shoulders would creep up. My jaw would lock, and my heartbeat would start slamming every time the matriarch said my name in that soft dead voice she uses when she wants a whole table to feel how easy it would be to cut me out of the will and blame me for it. Emotionally it would get even uglier because the show would reward the very thing this family is best at, which is weaponized performance. The matriarch would not stop controlling. She would evolve. She would cry in the exact places that help her. She would speak about legacy and sacrifice, then standards and family stability, while somehow leaving out the years she spent humiliating people in measured doses so nobody else could call it abuse without sounding melodramatic. The cousins would split into camps based on who thinks they can get something out of the wreckage, whether that means money or sympathy or followers. Every real wound would grow a second parasite attached to it. Is this pain, or is this positioning. Is this confession, or is this audition. Once that starts, it never fully stops. Socially the show would rot everything it touched. Friends would become viewers. Strangers would become judges. Every date would come with that slanted little look, and every business meeting would come with it too, plus every loose conversation at a bar with people who think they already know your home life from ten edited scenes and a teaser trailer. The show would flatten us into roles. She becomes the iron matriarch. I get stuck as the unstable truth teller, and the rest of the family gets sorted into weaker little parts from there. Once the public gets those labels in their teeth, good luck prying them out again. There is also the system cost, and that bastard matters. A network does not want healing. A network wants return viewers. If one dinner gives them inheritance threats, then next week they want medication accusations. After that they want the next family wound that bleeds brightest through a sponsor break, whether that means hidden debt or secret lovers or something even filthier. The whole format would train the room to escalate. Calm would become dead airtime. Boundaries would become selfishness. Any attempt to protect one another would get treated like bad television. That is how the machine would crawl inside the bloodline and start rearranging it from the inside. Still, the reality show has one brutal virtue the other option does not have. The trap stays visible. If the family is exploiting me in public, I can point to the camera, the producer, the release form, the boom mic, the whole circus. I can walk off. I can refuse another season. I can call it what it is without pretending the damage came from nowhere. Being humiliated in public is hideous. I am not dressing it up. But at least the humiliation has a face and a payroll department. Now let me get to the N D A side, because this is the one that comes dressed like good manners while it does the darker work. Sign the paper. Respect the family and protect private matters, then pretend that means you are not damaging the legacy. That is how they sell it. What it really means is that the matriarch gets permanent first rights over reality. She gets to define what happened, what counted, who overreacted, who betrayed whom, and why Tommy is supposedly difficult every time he refuses to sit still and be managed. The body cost of that silence is slower and meaner than the public option. Public humiliation spikes hard. Private gagging just keeps pressing on the same bruise until your whole nervous system starts building its life around the bruise. You hear a lie at dinner and say nothing. Another one comes at Easter, and then somebody repeats family mythology at a funeral while saying Tommy always had a dramatic streak. You stand there feeling the heat climb your spine while the contract sits in your pocket like a tiny loaded gun pointed inward. That kind of silence trains the body into cowardice by repetition. It teaches your muscles that swallowing rage is the price of belonging. Emotionally it is poison because it steals authorship over your own life. Huge parts of me only make sense if I am allowed to say where they came from. Why I hate certain tones of voice. Why compliments from controlling people make my skin crawl, and why Sunday afternoons can make me feel like a trapped animal even when the room is technically polite. If I sign the N D A, then all of that context gets locked up. I become the visible result of an invisible system. To everybody outside the family, I just look moody and unstable, with defensive little flinches that seem to come from nowhere. That is a filthy thing to do to a person. It makes the injury disappear and leaves the symptoms standing there to take the blame. The false hope on this side is peace. They always sell silence as peace. Sign this and the household settles down. The cousins stop whispering, the money stays smooth, and the matriarch gets to smile at holidays again. But that is not peace. That is hostage management. The room feels calmer because the one person who might contradict the official story has been contractually neutralized. Of course the surface looks nicer after that. Graveyards are neat too. Socially it is even more crooked. The family gets to keep speaking. I do not. The lawyer gets to hint, the cousins get to spin, and the matriarch gets to sigh in public about how painful it is when one branch of the family insists on dramatics. Every person loyal to her keeps full access to their voice while I am the only bastard expected to call silence maturity. That means every new room starts tilted against me before I even open the door. People hear the family version first. People always do. If I cannot answer it, then the lie calcifies. And this is where the real ugliness shows itself. Silence under contract does not stay contained. Once the family learns I can be bought into quiet, the quiet will need maintenance. Another document shows up. Then a side agreement follows, and after that comes one more little warning that certain details are better left alone if I value access or housing or trust funds. The first paper never ends it. The first paper proves the method works. The generational damage on that side is rancid. Children watch how truth gets handled in a family. Younger cousins notice who is allowed to narrate and who is expected to absorb. If I sign, I help teach the next round that power does not need to be right. It only needs better lawyers and enough money to turn memory into breach of contract. The matriarch would love that. She does not care if people agree with her in their hearts. She only cares that the story survives after her fingerprints get wiped off it. The room is telling me all this before anybody speaks. The lawyer keeps one hand on the folder like he already knows which future professional families usually choose. The cousins will not meet my eyes. The matriarch has that still expression she uses when she thinks the battle is already over and the only remaining question is whether I am going to surrender gracefully or make a scene she can later call regrettable. That is the whole disease right there. This family thinks refusing erasure is bad manners. So I run both endings all the way out. If I choose the reality show, I invite public filth into the house and the house will absolutely answer by giving the public something foul to chew on. I will lose privacy. Peace goes with it, and I will probably say things on camera that I would rather have left inside my own skull. The family will mutate under the gaze. It will get tackier. Crueler in new ways, and more theatrical for all the wrong reasons. All true. But if I choose the N D A, I lose the right to contest the story of my own life. I become a decorative witness to my own distortion. I get to sit in expensive rooms while everybody else tells prettier lies about why this family functions the way it does. That is the slower death. Not because it is louder. Because it is cleaner. It makes self betrayal look like maturity, then lets the matriarch keep her throne while I do the labor of amputating my own tongue and calling that respect. I choose Matriarch Reality Show. I choose Matriarch Reality Show because a fucking public bloodbath is still better than a motherfucker silence contract that asks me to help bury my own reality under good china and legal stationery. The show side is ugly and cheap, with cameras that would love to catch me cracking in high definition. Fine. I can still name that trap while I am inside it. The N D A side is worse because it turns me into a polished hostage and calls that family honor. That losing side is a rich old humiliation machine. It wants my voice and my memory, then expects the nerve to thank it for the privilege. The matriarch can have her pearls. The lawyer can keep his folder. I am not signing away my mouth so the family lie gets one more generation to sit at the head of the table. That's the fucking verdict. I made the call, and if your brain still works, you know where this lands.