Would You Rather · Episode 24
Grandma Cult
2,731 words
Get ready, Tommy the Hamburger is about to twist your motherfucking brain. You're going to get two choices, and an examination of the fucking thought process behind both. Shit's about to get detailed and complicated, so you better pay attention.
All right. Here is the motherfucking dilemma.
Would you rather keep your grandma's fucking fan cult alive by putting on her robe, leading the meetings, and feeding lonely people one more polished version of her holiness, or shut the whole thing down and climb onto a motherfucker apology tour bus to tell the country who she really was and who she hurt?
I am standing in the sewing room she used to run like a private kingdom. The place smells like candle wax and dusty curtains, with old hand lotion and stale peppermints sitting under church perfume and that damp sweet smell old houses get when grief has been shut indoors too long. The wallpaper is faded. The overhead bulb is yellow and mean. A stack of cream robes sits on a folding table beside a coffee tin full of cash donations and sympathy notes written in shaky handwriting. On the far wall there are framed photos of grandma smiling that hard little smile she used when she wanted gratitude to feel mandatory. Through the window I can see a tour bus idling in the driveway with sponsor decals shining on the side like somebody found a way to monetize confession before I even agreed to make one. Fuck me sideways, one choice turns me into the next keeper of the shrine. The other drags me out on the road to apologize for damage this family spent years calling discipline.
Nobody in the room will say cult out loud, which is how you know it is one. They call it the Circle. They call it remembrance. Then they pile on all the usual holy little nicknames people give a control system when they want it to keep running after the original bastard dies. Grandma is buried. Fine. Her posture still runs the room. Her phrases still run the room, and her rules about loyalty and appearance still run the room right along with her ideas about pain and ingratitude. The dead woman lost her pulse and kept the leverage.
If I choose the cult, I stay here, put on the robe, hold the meetings, repeat the official stories, collect the offerings, and act like I am honoring a saint instead of extending a family scam with softer lighting. If I choose the apology tour, I blow up the local comfort, climb on that bus, and spend months walking into rooms all over the country to tell people exactly how grandma used religion and grief, then money and shame, to build herself into a domestic empire. Neither side is clean. One is obedience in costume. The other is public disgrace with mileage.
The cult side has a nasty kind of appeal, and I am not going to lie about that just to sound principled. Running the room means control. Control over which stories survive and what the atmosphere feels like, plus who gets welcomed close and who gets frozen out as disrespectful. If you were raised by people who made power feel like the only protection available, then inheriting the machine starts sounding almost responsible. It feels safer if I am the one holding it instead of some cousin with dead eyes and a hunger for titles, or some outsider who sees the whole room as a grief mine full of easy money. It also feels safer than letting grandma's favorite phrases get picked up by somebody too stupid to know where the blood is under them.
That is how the trap talks. It never opens with greed. It opens with stewardship. It says you understand the damage better than anyone else, so surely you are the safest person to manage the remains. Maybe you could soften it and take the sharper edges off. Maybe you could redirect it into harmless rituals and little remembrance nights, or candle walks and scholarships with grandma's name on them. Maybe you could keep the widows and lonely cousins from being devoured by somebody worse. That lie is seductive because it wears the face of care.
But the body cost would start almost immediately. To run a cult you have to live in atmosphere. You have to maintain the room. Maintain the lighting and the tone, then keep the hush at exactly the right level while the emotional weather stays open enough to believe but not steady enough to question. I would spend my days breathing candle smoke and stale coffee, with laundry soap trapped in cloth robes mixing into the hot nervous breath of people who come here because they need grandma to still mean something. I would have to stand in the center of all that need and keep my own face arranged just right. Not too cold. Not too human. Warm enough to soothe, and certain enough to stop doubt before it gets contagious. That kind of posture gets into the back and neck fast. You end up carrying fake serenity in the muscles like a crate.
Emotionally it is uglier because the whole job depends on preserving a lie about the dead. Grandma was not pure guidance. She was not clean wisdom. She was not some sweet old matriarch who loved hard and demanded a lot because times were different. She was brilliant at moral pressure. She could make generosity feel like debt in under a minute. She could turn a dinner prayer into an indictment. She could shame people so gently they thanked her for it while their stomach folded in half. If I run the cult, I have to keep trimming those facts out every time they threaten the story. I have to stand there while people project safety onto a woman who taught half this family to mistake fear for respect.
And that would rot me from the inside because the people showing up here are not cartoon fools. They are damaged in ordinary ways. Lonely, bereaved, guilty, hungry for order, scared of dying without belonging anywhere solid. The robe room would fill up with people who want a structure to kneel inside because the world kicked the shit out of them and grandma's memory sounds steadier than their own lives. If I keep the place going, I would be using real need as fuel. Every tear becomes proof the Circle matters. Every donation becomes proof the work must continue. Every person who feels seen gets turned into one more reason not to ask what exactly they are being initiated into. That is predatory, even if I do it with softer language than grandma used.
The social cost on that side is pure stickiness. The second I become leader, everybody starts leaning with an angle. One cousin wants access to the money. An aunt wants a title she can wear like jewelry, and some former member comes back hoping this time the room will finally love her back. Then one man with blank wet eyes starts treating the robe like a marriage proposal from destiny. There is no clean friendship left in a structure like that. Every kindness becomes recruitment. Every disagreement becomes heresy. Every boundary gets interpreted as a wound in the community. The room would start eating my entire social life because cults hate outside air.
Then comes the system cost, and this is where the thing shows its real teeth. If the cult survives one more year, it will need paperwork. First come the calendars and retreats. Then donor systems and memorial junk start piling up, and after that somebody wants a nonprofit shell or a counseling branch or whatever legal buffer keeps the room alive when a victim finally says enough. Machines like this never stay small if they keep getting fed. They professionalize. They learn how to defend themselves. Soon grandma's robe room becomes a tax efficient grief industry with volunteers smiling at the door while they hand out mugs and policy forms.
Still, I have to admit the cult side has one miserable advantage. The poison stays local. I know the room. I know the faces. I know the rhythm of the lies and the exact pitch of the silence right before someone starts crying. If I am trapped here, at least I can smell the trap. I can look at the robe stack and know exactly what kind of skin the room wants me to wear.
Now let me get to the apology tour, because that one comes wrapped in moral clarity and is still full of teeth. Burn the robes and cancel the meetings. Open the records, hit the road, and tell the truth in every town where grandma left a bruise. There is something clean about imagining that. I understand why it pulls so hard. Part of me wants to rip the whole shrine down, toss the ashes in a box, and spend six months making sure nobody ever gets to say she was merely strict or old fashioned again. The road promises exposure. The road promises motion, and it promises that the damage gets pushed outward instead of recirculated through one more beige room full of obedient grief.
That is the false hope on this side. Confession is not magic. A bus route is not justice. Some people do not want to hear from the grandson. Other people got hurt so badly by grandma that hearing me speak for two hours in a ticketed venue would feel like one more insult. A few want silence. Others want money or names, and some just want me to shut up and stop turning their injury into an event. If I choose the tour, I do not step into purity. I step into public process, and public process is always crawling with middlemen who smell opportunity.
The body cost would be savage. Buses wreck the spine. Gas station coffee strips the stomach lining, and motel air makes the throat feel sanded. You wake in one state and fall asleep in another with your shoes still half on because some local reporter cornered you after the event and asked whether grandma's cruelty came from trauma, as if an explanation is the same thing as an excuse. Night after night I would have to stand under lights and narrate the anatomy of a dead woman's damage while strangers stare at me deciding whether I sound sincere enough to justify their ticket price. That is not catharsis. That is an endurance sport for shame.
Emotionally the road might be even worse because it refuses numbness. In the robe room I would be preserving a lie. On the bus I would be cutting through one. Every stop would bring fresh testimony. Maybe it is a church singer who got humiliated until she quit performing. Maybe it is a nephew who only got loaned money so grandma could own his gratitude forever, or a caregiver who got underpaid while being told it was character building. Then some old friend shows up after thirty years of wondering whether she was crazy because grandma could charm a whole block after privately tearing somebody to strips. I would have to hear all of it. Worse, I would have to accept that my own grief does not outrank theirs just because I had the blood relation. That kind of reordering hurts.
The social trap on the tour is vicious in a different way. Journalists want a neat arc. Sponsors push for marketable honesty while audiences chase spectacle disguised as healing. Family members who kept quiet for years suddenly want their own stage time and their own correction, with one more turn at the microphone if they can get it. Half of them want truth. Another chunk wants revenge, and the rest want attention. Fine, that is messy math, but that is what a family wreck feels like. Too many claims at once, all of them sticky. The road would turn every stop into a sorting table for pain and ego, with memory and performance getting tangled right into it.
There is a system cost there too, and I do not get to pretend otherwise just because this side sounds morally superior. If the apology tour works, then it starts generating demand. More cities show up. Bigger rooms follow, and then somebody starts asking about streaming rights and documentary interest. Some monster in a blazer will eventually suggest that maybe the robe from the original Circle could travel in a glass case as part of the exhibit because audiences love a visual anchor. That is how fast accountability can mutate into commerce. You start out trying to tell the truth and end up one producer meeting away from selling souvenir candles shaped like conscience.
But this side has one advantage I cannot talk my way around. The pressure moves in the right direction. In the cult, the whole point is to keep feeding grief back into devotion so the dead stay powerful and the living stay arranged around them. On the tour, whatever else goes wrong, the center shifts away from grandma's myth and toward the people she bent. The road may exploit me. The road may exploit them. The road may get tacky and ugly and opportunistic in places. Even then, it is still pointed closer to truth than the robe room is. The robe room exists to preserve her authority after death. The tour exists to break that authority open and let air hit it.
The room is proving it right now. A woman in the front row of folding chairs is stroking the sleeve of one robe with her thumb like she thinks the cloth can still pass her a blessing. My cousin near the coat rack keeps watching my hands instead of my face because the second I touch that robe he will know which version of the family gets to survive. Outside, the bus keeps idling, patient as a sentence I have been avoiding for years. Inside, everybody wants atmosphere. Outside, consequence is parked in the driveway with the engine running.
So I walk both endings all the way out. If I choose the cult, I get local control and steady money, with ritual power sitting right beside a room full of people ready to hand me their hurt and call me necessary. I also become the next mouthpiece for a lie that already damaged enough lives. I keep grandma ruling by remote. I teach fresh people to kneel in an atmosphere that was built from obligation and fear. I turn grief into inventory. That is disgusting.
If I choose the apology tour, comfort goes first. Privacy goes with it, and the right to be merely a grandson with mixed feelings disappears under the job of publicly carrying a family indictment. I get worn down and doubted, then cornered by people who want cleaner answers than real life gives. Grandma's filth still sticks to me in ways that will cling long after the bus stops moving. Fine. But I also stop feeding the room that made the filth feel holy. Instead of laundering manipulation through robes and candlelight, I start warning damaged people away from kneeling in the place that trained them to.
So I choose Public Apology Tour.
I choose Public Apology Tour because a fucking brutal road of confession is still better than a motherfucker grief cult that keeps grandma's control alive by dressing it up as comfort. The bus side is exhausting and public, with new ways for people to profit off the wreck crawling out from every corner. I know that. I would still rather fight those bastards in daylight than stand in this room wearing her costume and pretending exploitation turns sacred if you light enough candles around it. Grandma Cult is worse because it traps lonely people inside a lie and teaches them to call obedience healing. That losing side is a soft voiced humiliation machine in borrowed robes. I will take the hard road, the ugly names, the bad motels, and the public mess before I spend one more year helping a dead woman keep her hand around this family's throat.
That's the fucking verdict. I made the call, and if your brain still works, you know where this lands.