Tommy

Would You Rather · Episode 25

Ancestor Jury

2,412 words

Get ready, Tommy the Hamburger is about to twist your motherfucking brain. You're going to get two choices, and an examination of the fucking thought process behind both. Shit's about to get detailed and complicated, so you better pay attention. All right. Here is the motherfucking dilemma. Would you rather let your fucking ancestors vote on every major decision you make from now on, or ignore the whole ghost committee and pay a motherfucker cultural tax every month for refusing to live under their supervision? I am standing in the family archive room where everybody suddenly starts whispering like history gets offended by normal volume. The place smells like cedar shelves and lamp heat, with dust baked into old paper sitting under cold incense and the coppery little tang of coins passed through too many anxious hands. Photo albums are stacked like bricks. Framed certificates stare down from the wall. One table has prayer sticks with a bowl of ash, marked stones, and a brass bell waiting to turn my future into ceremony. The other table has forms from the heritage board beside a stamp pad and a calculator that keeps flashing new totals like the bastard thing is enjoying itself. Fuck me sideways, one side makes my life a permanent appeal to the dead. The other side makes freedom feel like a bill collector with ceremonial language. This room is what happens when memory gets promoted into enforcement. Nobody here says that out loud, of course. They say continuity. They say duty, then roots and respect, while what they really mean is that the past wants a seat at the table and it does not intend to sit quietly. In this family, the dead never stayed dead in any useful sense. They stayed quoted. They stayed invoked, then got dragged into arguments they never asked to attend. A living relative wants control, and suddenly some grandfather who died before color television is supposedly furious about my haircut and job, or my apartment and sex life, or my whole goddamn metabolism if the room needs one more reason to supervise me. If I choose the ancestor jury, then every major call gets routed through ritual. Career moves and love. Money and housing. Travel, children, health decisions, and any other risk the room feels hungry enough to grab. I burn the incense, lay out the stones, listen to the dream reports, hear the elder interpretations, and let the dead cast their votes through whatever sign the living decide counts this week. If I choose the cultural tax, then I reject all of that and pay for the refusal in hard cash every month, because the heritage board says anyone who opts out of the old guidance structure owes compensation to the community they supposedly damaged by becoming their own person. That is a rotten pair of hands around the throat. Either I surrender my judgment to ghosts, or I rent my judgment back from a ledger. The ancestor jury side has a pull to it, and I am not going to act too evolved to admit that. There is comfort in being told you are not alone with a decision. There is comfort in feeling watched over instead of merely watched. When life gets mean, the idea that your people still care from beyond the dirt can hit like warm food after a bad week. You start wanting instruction. You start wanting permission. You start wanting somebody older than your own fear to say yes or no, or maybe wait a little longer before you trust this person or sign that paper or leave that city. It sounds intimate. It sounds rooted. It sounds like the opposite of modern drift. That is exactly why it is dangerous. The trap does not begin with domination. It begins with relief. Maybe I do not have to carry the whole burden of choosing alone. Maybe the dead already know what will break me. Maybe they can see farther. Maybe the signs mean something. Maybe the dream about my great grandmother in the blue house is not just a dream. Maybe the cracked dish is a warning, or the bird at the sill means stop, or the ash pattern means wait. Once that thinking gets its claws in, every random little twitch of reality starts applying for authority. The body cost on that side would be brutal in a sneaky way. I would stop relaxing around my own life. Every headache becomes a possible message. Every missed train becomes an omen, and every little accident gets pulled into the evidence pile. The nervous system never gets to call anything ordinary again. Spill coffee and it becomes caution. Get anxious before a meeting and it becomes ancestral resistance. Sleep badly one night and suddenly you failed to listen. That sort of structure turns the body into a haunted instrument panel. Constant scanning. Constant second guessing, with stupid little flares of dread because maybe the dead are displeased and this sore throat is how they filed the complaint. Emotionally it is even nastier because it steals adulthood one decision at a time. If the jury gets a vote on everything, then I never fully own anything. If a choice works out, the family says I was wise enough to listen. If it fails, then I either misread the signs or disrespected them. There is no clean win left in that. Love gets contaminated. Ambition gets contaminated. Grief gets contaminated. You end up standing in your own life like a temporary custodian instead of a person. I know exactly what would happen to me. I would start hesitating before anything irreversible. Not because I lacked nerve, but because I would have been trained to believe that choosing alone is arrogance. That is a filthy lesson to staple into somebody's spine. Then the living parasites come running, because they always do. The moment you let the dead vote, every control freak with a pulse suddenly becomes an election official. The aunt who has been waiting twenty years to meddle in my life becomes spiritually sensitive. The cousin with no discipline becomes the interpreter of dreams, and the uncle who drinks too much but loves authority suddenly guards proper ritual. Some local medium with a face full of fake sorrow starts charging consultation fees. The priest wants procedure. The family elder wants deference. All that ghost talk creates the perfect hiding place for ordinary power hungry bastards. That is what makes me angriest about the whole setup. It pretends to honor the dead while handing extra leverage to the living. And once it gets normalized, of course it grows rules. Somebody decides who gets to read the ash and what qualifies as a binding sign. Then the room starts arguing about whether conflicting messages require a second sitting, or whether marriages and moves need ancestral consent before anyone packs a bag. The minute a ritual structure touches power, it starts growing procedure like mold in a damp wall. Soon it is not enough to honor the ancestors. You need approved methods and approved readers, with approved rooms and phrasing waiting for the exact second somebody like Tommy says this whole setup smells like a control scheme with nicer wallpaper. Still, I have to admit the ancestor jury offers one thing the tax never will. It offers closeness. Maybe false closeness. Maybe manipulated closeness. Fine. It still puts belonging on the table. It says you are held. You are part of something older than your own panic. You are not making these decisions in a vacuum. Even a warped embrace can feel better than a clean invoice when you are tired enough. Now let me get to the cultural tax, because this one sounds practical and manages to be colder. If I refuse the rituals, if I say the dead do not get to supervise my adult life, then the board sends a monthly assessment. They say the payment helps preserve heritage programming and archives, or festivals and language schools, or whatever pretty civic label makes extortion sound educational this quarter. But the emotional truth of it is simple. They are charging me for self possession. They are telling me autonomy has a tariff. The body cost there is not mystical. It is steady grinding resentment. Every month money leaves my account because I declined to surrender my choices to a ghost council. Rent still exists. Food and repairs still exist, and life keeps biting right on schedule. Then this extra deduction arrives with formal language and a stamped seal to remind me that freedom, in this system, is not a right. It is a premium option. That kind of pressure lives in the jaw. You start opening the mailbox like you are reaching into a trap. You start checking your balance with the same stale anger every time. The body knows the insult even when the paperwork uses polite fonts. Emotionally it gets crueler the longer it runs because the payment becomes a running narration over every choice. Moving costs more now. Refusing the festival costs more now, and raising your kids without ritual oversight comes with its own little penalty humming in the background. After enough months of that, even the idea of marrying outside expectation shows up wearing a price tag. The tax teaches you to think of freedom as a leak in your finances. After enough months of that, even your cleanest independent thought arrives wearing a price tag. That is a disgusting thing to do to a person's interior life. The social trap on this side is ugly in a different costume. The loyal ones get moral high ground. The taxed ones get treated like defectors. Family elders point at the receipts and say see, even the board knows you owe something. Cousins who stayed obedient get to smirk and talk about how expensive modern selfishness is, while bureaucrats who never sat in grandma's kitchen suddenly get to rate how culturally accountable I am this quarter. There is something especially rotten about that. On the jury side, at least the pressure comes in family language. On the tax side, the pressure gets laminated and filed. And because it is a revenue system, it grows an appetite. First there is the base payment. Then a review fee and a late fee show up, and after that comes some compliance hearing or reduced rate scam if you attend enough approved events to prove your refusal is not complete. Systems built around extraction never look at a working model and say beautiful, let us stop here. They start nibbling at every seam until the whole structure depends on keeping people like me in the taxable category forever. There is false hope on this side too, and I know exactly how it would talk to me. Just pay it and move on. Keep your head down. Let money absorb the conflict and keep your evenings free. No bells and no stones, with no mediums and no dream tribunal waiting to tell you what the ancestors think of your girlfriend's voice. Just write the check and own yourself quietly. That sounds practical right up until you understand what the payment teaches the system. It teaches them the model works. It teaches them independence can be monetized, and that you will swallow public insult if the receipt is polished enough. But even with all that filth, the tax has one brutal advantage I cannot ignore. The enemy stays visible. It is the board and the form, the statute and the line item, the monthly wound with a reference number sitting right there where I can point at it. I can hate that directly. I can organize against it. I can expose it and drag it into court or public speech or any ugly fight where everybody has to say what they are really doing. The ancestor jury is slipperier. You cannot cross examine a dream. You cannot subpoena a crow. You cannot argue cleanly with a ritual structure that keeps borrowing the dead every time the living want more leverage. The room is showing me the split right now. The incense ash has blown sideways over the wood and everybody on that end of the table is already pretending it means something. On the money side the calculator blinks again after the clerk presses one fat finger into the keypad, and the number jumps like it enjoys tightening the collar. That is the whole problem in one glance. One side wants me kneeling. The other wants me paying, and both want me reminded that my life belongs upstream to something older and meaner than my own judgment. So I run both endings out as far as they go. If I choose the ancestor jury, I get belonging, story, ritual, and the narcotic comfort of feeling guided. I also give up clean ownership of my own life and invite every manipulative bastard in the family to start speaking with ghost authority. My future becomes a supervised process. My instincts become suspect. My adulthood gets demoted into a temporary license pending ancestral approval. That is unbearable. If I choose the cultural tax, I get punished in plain sight. I lose money. I probably lose sleep. I definitely lose patience. I watch a piece of every paycheck disappear because some heritage office thinks choosing alone is a civic injury. That is vile. Still, when I make a decision, it stays mine. Expensive, yes. Bitter, yes. Mine. Nobody gets to wave a smoking bowl at me and say the dead have overruled my lungs, my work, my bed, my future. So I choose Cultural Tax. I choose Cultural Tax because I would rather carry a fucking visible financial wound than spend the rest of my life answering to a motherfucker jury assembled from dead relatives and living control freaks wearing borrowed sanctity. The tax side is extortion, plain and ugly. I know that. I can still fight something I can name. Ancestor Jury is worse because it wants my judgment hollowed out from the inside until obedience starts sounding like reverence. That losing side is a spiritual humiliation machine with family photos nailed to the walls. Let the board send the bill. Let the clerk stamp the forms. I will take open theft over haunted supervision every single time. That's the fucking verdict. I made the call, and if your brain still works, you know where this lands.