Would You Rather · Episode 34
Ex Wedding Officiant
2,074 words
Get ready, Tommy the Hamburger is about to twist your motherfucking brain. You're going to get two choices, and an examination of the fucking thought process behind both. Shit's about to get detailed and complicated, so you better pay attention.
All right. Here is the motherfucking dilemma.
Would you rather officiate your ex's wedding on livestream, or skip it and pay a family imposed fine that follows you through every reunion and every whispered conversation after that? I am standing in the side corridor outside the banquet hall, and the whole place smells like lilies and floor polish, with expensive food sitting under warming lamps just long enough to get greasy at the edges. The rented jacket on my shoulders feels too stiff. My collar is chewing at my neck. Through the open doors I can hear the string quartet scraping away at joy like they are getting paid extra for every fake smile in the room. On one side of me is the ceremony packet with the vows and ring cue, plus the little script that would make me the mouthpiece for my own replacement. On the other side is the family fine document with numbers and signatures, plus enough smug little penalty clauses to prove somebody enjoyed writing them. One side asks me to stand at the altar and bless the woman who broke me. The other side asks me to refuse and then keep paying for that refusal long after the chairs are folded up.
Option one is Ex Wedding Officiant. I walk out there in front of the cameras, smile like a good sport, and perform the ceremony while my ex and her new husband build a fresh happy memory on top of my old wreckage. Option two is Family Fine. I turn around, leave the building, and let the bloodline punish me in cash and gossip for refusing to become a decorative piece in their little pageant. Fuck me sideways, this is not a test of maturity. This is a choice between public humiliation and controlled extortion.
Let me drag Ex Wedding Officiant under the light first. I know why everybody pretends this side is noble. It lets the family talk about grace and say I rose above the old hurt. It gives my ex a beautiful story where everyone behaved like civilized adults and history got tucked into a tasteful little box before dessert was served. On paper it sounds clean and evolved, which is exactly why people praise it. They do not have to be the bastard standing at the microphone with the old knife still in his ribs.
That is the false hope on this side. The officiant route says if I play along, I get closure. It says facing the wound directly will prove I am bigger than it. Maybe I even tell myself the livestream will catch me looking calm and untouchable, like I turned the whole trap into my own show and walked out taller. That is the same lie people tell themselves before every public humiliation they are too embarrassed to call what it is. There is no magic transformation hidden inside forced dignity. Sometimes pain does not become wisdom. Sometimes it just becomes footage.
The body cost starts before the ceremony even begins. My stomach is already tight enough to feel like a fist, and my jaw keeps locking while sweat collects behind my knees in this rented suit like my whole nervous system knows I am about to do something stupid and is begging me to stop. If I walk onto that stage and start reading the script, then every second becomes a bodily argument between posture and panic. I would have to keep the page steady and the voice level without letting the camera catch the blink that comes right before the memories surge. That kind of control is exhausting because it is not performance. It is containment.
The emotional cost is filthier. Weddings are already built to weaponize memory. Every flower and every song in the room is there to support the lines about devotion and tell a story about who belongs together. If I officiate, then I have to narrate that story while knowing I once thought it might have been mine. I have to stand close enough to smell her perfume and act like my chest is not reopening in real time. Then I have to say the little ceremonial lines that turn private loss into public acceptance. There is no closure in that. There is only self betrayal wearing a polite voice.
The social trap is brutal because everybody in the room will call it brave when what they really mean is convenient. They will praise my character only because I made the room easier for everybody else. I become the sponge for all the awkwardness they did not want touching the napkins and the cake table.
The system cost is what really turns this into a humiliation machine. The livestream does not just capture the ceremony. It preserves it. The clips and reposts will spread, and the relatives will start sending each other timestamps with little comments about how composed I looked, which is another way of saying look at the bastard smiling while his own story gets buried alive in high definition. Once a humiliation gets archived, it stops being an event and starts being a renewable resource for anyone who wants to revisit it.
Still, Ex Wedding Officiant has one hard advantage over the fine. If I do it, the punishment ends in one shot. I take the hit, leave the hall, and nobody gets to invoice me for years afterward. There is a savage simplicity to that. One rotten moment can be easier to survive than a long drip of penalties if the wound closes fast enough after the blow lands.
Now let me tear into Family Fine, because this one looks practical and still arrives carrying poison. Refusing the ceremony sounds like self respect. It sounds like the clean answer a sane man would choose. Keep your distance and protect your chest while somebody else pronounces the vows. I know the appeal because my whole body wants the door more than the altar. Walking out means I do not have to stand there as living proof that families will make a man decorate his own loss if the table settings are expensive enough.
That is the false hope here. The fine route whispers that money pain is manageable. It says this is just arithmetic. Pay the number and ignore the talk, then keep moving. Maybe I even tell myself the gossip will burn out because people always need fresh meat eventually. Maybe I imagine I can absorb the bill and let the whole ugly thing shrink into a story about boundaries. That fantasy only works if the family fine is really about money. It never is. The money is just the leash.
The body cost on this side is slower and uglier. Every payment becomes another tightening in the gut. Every family message becomes a pulse spike before I even open it. If they set the fine up the way these bloodline control freaks always do, then it will come with late fees and shame add ons, with the rest buried inside petty moral bookkeeping disguised as tradition. My body would stop reacting to one catastrophic moment and start reacting to a long campaign of needling. That kind of stress gets in your sleep. It sits on your chest at four in the morning and asks whether next month is going to be worse.
The emotional cost is different from the officiant route, but it still stinks. Refusing the wedding means the family gets a cleaner villain. They will act like I made the day about myself and like my ex was gracious while I was bitter. Then they will call the fine consequence instead of punishment, which is what cowards say when they want cruelty to sound organized. The longer that story lives, the more every future gathering becomes a little trial where I am expected to either apologize or keep paying in attitude.
The social trap is relentless because families love a ledger when they know it is strapped to somebody else's throat. Suddenly everybody gets to talk about honoring the occasion while pretending this is about respect even though everybody knows it is really about obedience. Once the fine exists, it gives every controlling motherfucker in the bloodline a tool. They will not stop at one ceremony. They will remember how effective it was and start reaching for the same weapon every time somebody disappoints the room.
The system cost is the part that makes this side dangerous. A family fine is never just a number. It becomes a structure with committee logic and some fake appeal process designed by the same bastards who set the amount in the first place. There is always extra pressure tied to housing help and business ties, plus whatever other little channels the family uses to make sure money becomes social control. Once I accept the principle that they can bill me for protecting myself, I am not paying one fee. I am endorsing a jurisdiction over my spine.
But Family Fine does have one savage advantage over the officiant route. It keeps my mouth off the microphone. It keeps me from narrating her joy like a polite undertaker at the funeral of my own history. That matters more than the family wants to admit. There are some acts that stain a man in a very specific way, and saying the vows for your ex while the cameras feed on your face is one of them.
The room proves the split while I stand here. Through the doorway I can see the altar arch glowing under soft lights like a trap dressed up as tenderness. On the table beside me, the ceremony packet lies open to the part where I would invite the guests to witness the union. The fine document is clipped beneath a gold pen with my aunt's little sticky note on top, like extortion became classy because somebody used good stationery. That is the whole game. One side wants my voice. The other side wants my compliance in installments.
So let me walk both endings all the way out. If I choose Ex Wedding Officiant, I spare myself the years of family billing and I keep the ledger from taking root. I also hand the room exactly what it wants, which is my public cooperation in turning heartbreak into content. That is a trap with a boutonniere pinned to it.
If I choose Family Fine, I pay through the nose and I give the family a long runway for gossip and punishment. I also keep one thing they cannot buy back from me, which is my mouth at that altar. That is ugly and expensive. It is still the better side.
I choose Family Fine.
I choose it because I would rather pay the fucking parasites than stand there like some obedient motherfucker blessing the woman who gutted me and the smiling bastard who gets the sequel. Let them fine me, and let them gossip while they build their little morality spreadsheet and pat themselves on the back for enforcing tradition. None of that is as bad as lending my own voice to the scene that would humiliate me forever.
Here is why the loser loses. Ex Wedding Officiant is a humiliation machine because it asks a man to convert heartbreak into pageantry and call that growth. It flatters everybody else in the room while it hollows out the one poor bastard forced to perform calm on camera. That is slower death wearing cuff links.
So I hand the ceremony packet back untouched and slide the fine document toward me instead. I tell my aunt to total it cleanly if she has the guts, because I am not giving these people a free clip of my face while my ex walks into her next chapter, and I tell the planner to find another mouth for the vows. Then I loosen the collar at my throat, push through the side door, and let the string quartet keep sawing away behind me while the first expensive little punishment starts rolling downhill.
That's the fucking verdict. I made the call, and if your brain still works, you know where this lands.