Tommy

Would You Rather · Episode 35

Parent Podcast

2,087 words

Get ready, Tommy the Hamburger is about to twist your motherfucking brain. You're going to get two choices, and an examination of the fucking thought process behind both. Shit's about to get detailed and complicated, so you better pay attention. All right. Here is the motherfucking dilemma. Would you rather produce your parents' tell all podcast, or censor them and get blacklisted from speaking at every family event after that? I am sitting in a cramped little studio that smells like hot wires and stale coffee, with old carpet underneath the chair and enough dust in the corners to prove nobody comes in here for anything healthy. The red recording light above the booth door keeps glaring at me like an accusation. My mother is on one side of the glass with her headphones half crooked. My father is on the other side rubbing his temples like the truth itself gave him a headache on the drive over. Between them sits the board with its levels and the power to either let the whole rotten bloodline hear itself out loud or clamp the lid back down and accept the punishment for doing it. One side turns me into the bastard who aired the family rot. The other side turns me into the bastard who helped bury it again and then lost his own voice as payment. Option one is Parent Podcast. I record the whole thing, edit it cleanly, and release my parents talking about the betrayals and the history everybody kept trimming down into polite little stories for children and holiday tables. Option two is Speaker Blacklist. I shut the mics off, protect the family facade, and accept that from that point on I am done speaking at weddings or funerals or any other family ritual where a microphone used to belong to me. Fuck me sideways, this is not a media choice. This is a choice between detonating the silence and letting silence claim me too. Let me drag Parent Podcast under the light first. I know exactly why this side hits so hard. It has the smell of release on it. You sit long enough inside a family built on careful omissions, and eventually truth starts looking like oxygen. My parents have been carrying old grievances and old betrayals around so long that their voices have started shaping themselves around the pressure. If I let them talk, maybe something unclenches and the poison has somewhere to go besides the next holiday dinner. Maybe the kids in this bloodline stop inheriting edited lies and start hearing what the adults actually did to each other. That is the false hope on this side. The podcast tells you exposure equals healing. It says if you put enough truth in the air, then the family has to deal with it honestly for once. Maybe I even tell myself I can produce it with enough restraint that it comes out sharp and useful without turning fake or soft. That is the lie every truth bomb tells before it goes off in a crowded room. Once the audio is out, it does not stay wise or balanced. It gets clipped and shared by anybody who wants the juicy part without the human part attached. The body cost starts in the booth. I know how sessions like this go. A hand starts trembling when somebody says the first real thing, then the pulse goes ugly and the room starts feeling hot because every memory landing on the table demands a reaction from the bodies still stuck in it. If I produce this, I am not just listening. I am riding the levels while my parents strip skin off old wounds that never healed right. Every intake of breath becomes a possible explosion. Every silence sounds loaded. That kind of sustained tension gets in your shoulders and stays there. The emotional cost is worse because I do not get to be a neutral technician. I am the son. If my mother starts talking about what my father hid, I know the rooms she cried in. If my father starts talking about the humiliations he swallowed, I know the way he went quiet for whole weekends and pretended it was work. Their stories are not content to me. They are pieces of the weather I grew up in. So every edit becomes a moral knife. Leave this line in and cut a relative open. Take it out and become one more coward smoothing over the bruise. The social trap is savage because families do not hear truth and think honesty. They hear threat. The minute the first episode drops, every aunt with a church voice and every uncle with a fake peacemaker act starts calling me reckless. The cousins will split, and nobody will thank me for being careful because careful does not exist once the family name gets dragged into public air. At that point I am either the brave one or the Judas, and families always choose the label that lets them avoid the substance. The system cost is what makes this side truly nasty. Podcasting turns confession into product whether you like it or not. There are feeds and clips with little summaries that make disaster sound tidy. Once the show exists, somebody will want the most explosive line cut into a teaser and somebody else will want titles that sell. Even if I do the work myself, the format still carries that stink. It wants narrative and escalation with another episode already lurking behind them. Still, Parent Podcast has one brutal advantage over the blacklist. It leaves me with my own voice intact. If I choose it, I stay the bastard holding the switch. I may burn bridges, but I do not voluntarily hand over my tongue to the same family machinery that created the rot in the first place. Now let me tear into Speaker Blacklist, because this one looks orderly and rots deeper. Censoring the show sounds responsible. It sounds like adulthood. Keep the damage contained and protect the elders while the younger relatives stay clear of history they did not ask for. I know the appeal because there is a part of me that wants the room quiet again right this second. A quiet room can feel like mercy when your parents are both one sentence away from making Christmas weird for the next twenty years. That is the false hope here. The blacklist says silence buys peace. It says if I kill the recording and take the family punishment, then at least the damage stays local. Maybe I imagine the old people calm down and the cousins move on and I keep enough private dignity to survive the hit. Maybe I even tell myself that losing podiums and microphones is no big deal because real life happens away from speeches anyway. That is the kind of bullshit a family invents when it wants obedience to sound mature. The body cost on this side arrives slower, but it sits deeper. The first time I get waved away from a wedding toast, my throat tightens, and the next time somebody else stands up at a funeral and tells a cleaned up version of a life I actually knew, my chest goes cold. When I reach for a microphone out of habit and some aunt puts her hand over it like I am a child reaching for a stove, that humiliation does not disappear when the event ends. It settles into posture. It teaches the body what it means to stay seated while lies keep getting the chair with the good view. The emotional cost is the part that really stinks. I have been the family speaker. I know the names and the accidents and the little details that keep dead people from being flattened into cardboard saints. If I accept the blacklist, I am not just giving up speaking time. I am agreeing that the family gets to decide who has moral permission to narrate our lives. That would gnaw at me every single time some cousin with a polished voice got up and told the safe version while I sat there swallowing the real one. The social trap is total because blacklists never stay neat. It starts with no speeches and then turns into quiet warnings that maybe I should not be at the planning meetings either. A family that learns it can punish one voice for refusing silence will keep expanding the punishment until the whole room learns the lesson. That is how cowards build culture. They shame one bastard in public, and everybody else starts editing themselves out of fear. The system cost is what makes this side unforgivable. Speaker Blacklist is not just a consequence. It is an institution. It creates a rule that the family can strip speech rights from anyone who threatens the official story. Once that exists, nobody with anything difficult to say is safe. Maybe it starts with me and then moves on to the niece who wants to mention the abuse nobody named, or the cousin who wants to say grandma was not kind just because she got old. I would not just be swallowing one insult. I would be helping install a censorship machine in the middle of the bloodline. But Speaker Blacklist does have one savage advantage. It keeps the darkest material off the public feed. It protects younger relatives from hearing the whole ugly backlog in a form that can be replayed forever. That matters. There is real danger in turning family ruin into audio that can travel further than the people who lived it. The room proves the split while I sit here. The mics in front of my parents look patient and hungry. The mute button on the board is one little square that could shove all this back underground with a finger press. Beside me is the event calendar my aunt dropped off earlier with little notes showing the ceremonies I would no longer speak at if I chose silence. Somebody actually highlighted the words no podium access like they were writing venue policy instead of punishing a son for refusing to bury more history. That is the whole trap. One side risks exposure. The other side turns obedience into tradition. So let me walk both endings all the way out. If I choose Parent Podcast, I release the truth and I keep my own voice. I also risk turning family damage into public fuel that strangers can consume with popcorn brains and no stake in the cost. That is a trap with studio foam on the walls. If I choose Speaker Blacklist, I keep the feed dark and the secrets contained for now. I also let the family install a permanent gag order over anyone who refuses their pretty little version of events. That is the worse trap. That is slower death in dress clothes. I choose Parent Podcast. I choose it because I would rather deal with the fucking blast than let some censorious motherfucker family council decide who gets to speak forever after this. If the truth burns, then let it burn in the open where people can finally see the shape of the house they kept pretending was fine. The feed is dangerous, the clips will spread, and some relatives will hate me until one of us dies. None of that is as bad as helping build a blacklist that teaches the whole bloodline to clap for silence. Here is why the loser loses. Speaker Blacklist is a humiliation machine because it takes one act of refusal and turns it into a standing rule that your voice belongs to the family only when it behaves. It does not preserve peace. It preserves hierarchy. That is a motherfucker trap built to make censorship look like decorum. So I lean over the board, bring the levels up, and tell my parents they get one honest pass at this with no performance and no fake martyr shit. If they name something, they name it cleanly, and the family group text can choke on the schedule change if it cannot survive one hour of truth. Then I hit record, feel the red light bite the room alive, and let the first terrible sentence finally come out where everybody can hear what this family has been asking silence to carry for all these years. That's the fucking verdict. I made the call, and if your brain still works, you know where this lands.