Would You Rather · Episode 64
Diet Roulette
2,586 words
Get ready, Tommy the Hamburger is about to twist your motherfucking brain. You're going to get two choices, and an examination of the fucking thought process behind both. Shit's about to get detailed and complicated, so you better pay attention.
All right. Here is the motherfucking dilemma.
Would you rather spin a giant wheel before every meal and eat whatever fate lands on, or force yourself to follow a diet designed by your biggest influencer rival?
We are not starting in some cute little nutrition blog fantasy. We are in a studio kitchen that smells like hot lights, bleach, and old fryer oil. The wheel is bolted to the floor next to a prep island. It is tall as a man and loud as hell when somebody slaps it. Your rival is leaning against the fridge with that smug dead eyed content face, arms folded, waiting to see whether the wheel ruins you or whether you hand them the keys to your stomach on purpose. Cameras watch from every corner while the live audience waits behind smoked glass. Somebody in a headset is counting down because apparently your breakfast has a release schedule now.
Fuck me sideways, this is exactly the kind of modern humiliation trap that gets sold as engagement.
The wheel option sounds freer for one stupid second. That is how it tricks you. You look at it and think random might be fair, or at least fair enough to let you shrug and say destiny gave me canned oysters blended with protein powder and hot syrup at breakfast, what can you do. The appeal is simple. Nobody hates me personally. You get to pretend the abuse has no author. That little illusion matters more than it should. People can survive a shocking amount of misery if nobody signs their name at the bottom of it.
Then the producer grabs the wheel and gives it a spin hard enough to make the whole set shake. Now you hear the clacking. You see the painted wedges flash past, each one carrying some new insult, maybe cold lamb fat or circus peanuts soaked in fish sauce with more ugliness waiting right behind them. Another wedge promises leftover movie theater nachos pressed into a waffle iron. One more offers plain oatmeal mixed with barbecue tuna because the audience likes it when the phrase sounds wrong. There is no mercy in that wheel because mercy is not the point. The point is suspense. The point is seeing your face when your body realizes breakfast just became a dare.
Every meal becomes a public execution with garnish. You do not get to shop or prep, and you definitely do not get to decide whether a given round calls for something gentle or heavy enough to pin your ribs down for hours. Your lunch could be six buttered dinner rolls dipped in melted ice cream. Your dinner could be a plate of liver, canned pears, and spicy pickle brine. The wheel does not care if you have work after. It also does not care that your stomach may already be raw from the last round or that what you really need is sleep and a moment of simple peace with a fork in your hand.
The real damage is not just digestive. It is psychological because meals are where people quietly hold themselves together. You wake up wrecked, but maybe you can make eggs and coffee and feel like a citizen again. You get hit by a rotten afternoon, but maybe dinner is rice, chicken, and something warm enough to convince your nervous system that life is not actively trying to drown you. The wheel takes that away. It turns every plate into an ambush. Soon you stop feeling hunger as a basic signal from your body and start feeling it as the drumroll before punishment. Your stomach growls and your heart answers with panic.
Think about the social part. Your friends ask if you want to grab dinner. You have to say maybe, depending on whether the wheel lands on sardine frosting or deep fried cottage cheese. You cannot make plans with normal people because your meals are now game show events. Even if they invite you out with good intentions, the whole table waits to see what your spin gives you. They do not mean to become spectators, but that is what the format does to them. It turns every human around you into somebody waiting for content.
There is also the body horror side, and that part gets uglier the longer it runs. Random food sounds funny if you are a bored asshole watching from a couch. It stops sounding funny when you live inside the consequences. Your skin changes and your sleep goes strange. Soon your guts are making threats in the middle of meetings. By the middle of the week you feel swollen and shaky enough to be genuinely afraid of trusting a fart in public. There is no rhythm for your system to adapt to because rhythm would count as kindness. One day you get nothing but heavy grease. The next day you are chewing dry cereal dust and spooning mustard into cottage cheese because the wheel loves contrast. Your body cannot train for nonsense.
Still, there is one dirty little advantage hiding inside the chaos. The wheel humiliates you, but it does not know you. That matters. It hurts you in the broad dumb way a hailstorm hurts a parked car. There is violence there, but no intimacy. Nobody sat down and studied your habits to design the perfect meal that would make you feel weak, ugly, inferior, or replaceable. If the wheel gives you steamed beets mashed into vanilla pudding, that is hideous, but it is not targeted. It is a random punch thrown by a machine built for ratings. You can hate it without feeling seen by it.
Now look at the rival diet, and tell me with a straight face that this one is kinder.
Your biggest influencer rival already knows your weak spots. They know which foods leave you feeling disgusting afterward and what kind of body image poison still lives under your ribs. They also know how certain smells can drag old memories out of the basement and slam them on the kitchen table. They have watched you panic around carbs and use caffeine like a substitute soul. They know because they watched you build your online self, and they built theirs in competition with it. If the wheel is anonymous cruelty, the rival diet is personalized warfare.
Do not imagine this rival as some cartoon supervillain with smoke coming out of the ears. That would almost be easier. Picture somebody polished enough to hide the knife in a smile. They frame the plan as healing and alignment, then claim it will free you from every flaw they can market as sickness. They hand you a PDF with color coded meal blocks and captions under every dish. Each caption sounds supportive until you realize it is just another way of saying your instincts are trash.
Breakfast on the rival plan is not merely food. It is a daily note from somebody who wants to rewrite you. Maybe they make you drink lukewarm celery broth before sunrise because they know you hate thin salty liquids. Maybe they lock you into joyless seed paste and rubber fruit because the point is not flavor. The point is obedience. That same philosophy follows you into the rest of the day until every bite says I know your body better than you do. Every swallow says your taste is childish, your habits are weak, and your old comfort foods were just evidence that you deserved to lose.
This is where the rival plan gets more dangerous than the wheel. The wheel ruins your meals. The rival colonizes your self concept. When the humiliation comes from a machine, you can keep a little island of identity intact. When it comes from a person who understands your vanity, your fear, your old hunger for approval, it gets inside the walls. You stop thinking I am suffering through bad meals. You start thinking they might be right, that your cravings are pathetic, and that hating the plan somehow proves you need somebody meaner than you running the kitchen.
That is how people get conquered without chains. They get handed a story that explains their pain as improvement.
Your rival would absolutely weaponize aesthetics too. The plating would be pristine, and the lighting would flatter the food enough to make every miserable bowl look expensive enough to trigger envy in strangers. You sit there chewing damp fennel and overcooked cod while the comments flood in about how elevated it looks, how clean it looks, how centered you seem. Meanwhile you feel like a hostage in linen. The wheel may force filth into your mouth, but the rival plan forces you to perform gratitude while you disappear in real time.
And there is no off switch inside that setup because the plan arrives with moral pressure attached to it. If you hate the wheel, everybody nods. Of course you hate the wheel. It just gave you cold spaghetti folded into yogurt. If you hate the rival diet, people accuse you of resisting growth. They start calling you self sabotaging and reciting the usual sermon about uncomfortable healing and discipline that hurts before it empowers. Suddenly your disgust is not evidence of torture. It is evidence against your character. That is a much nastier prison.
The social damage changes shape too. Under the wheel, your friends feel bad for you. Under the rival plan, your friends start debating whether the plan is actually smart. Before long the branding has worked on some of them, and recipe questions start coming in. Eventually somebody is telling you that your skin does look clearer even when you are half dead and chewing misery out of a ceramic bowl with tears in your eyes. You lose the right to call your own suffering by its real name because your rival packaged it as wellness and slapped a discount code on the caption.
I want to stay on that for a second because it is vile in a very current way. There is something uniquely disgusting about being erased by a narrative that claims to optimize you. If somebody beats you with a shovel, at least the crime scene tells the truth. If somebody grinds you down with a branded meal plan, the whole world starts complimenting the finish. They call you intentional while your spirit turns to chalk. They call you disciplined while you sit there fantasizing about one greasy honest cheeseburger that does not come with a sermon attached to it.
The rival also gets to edit the suffering over time. That is another reason this option scares me more. The wheel cannot learn. The rival can. Once they notice you are adapting to the raw vegetable garbage or secretly like the high protein sludge, they pivot. The second they realize fermented nonsense makes you gag, every third meal starts smelling like a damp basement in a jar. You are not only trapped inside their design. You are trapped inside a design that updates around your coping mechanisms. That is evil with feedback.
Some people would still pick the rival diet because they are terrified of chaos. I get it. There is an argument there. The rival plan at least has structure. You know when food is coming and what shape the misery will take, which can feel safer than handing your digestive tract to a lunatic wheel. Your stomach might hate the philosophy, but maybe your body would suffer less than it would under full random wheel law. Maybe the macros land in a reasonable zone. Maybe the meals are physically sustainable in a way the wheel never could be. If you are the kind of person who believes predictability is half of survival, that can sound worth a lot.
There is another argument for it that is harder to admit. Some people would rather be controlled than surprised. Surprise feels childish to them. Surprise means helplessness with confetti on top. They would rather submit to an enemy they can study than a machine they cannot bargain with. At least the rival has motives. At least a person can be outlasted, manipulated, shamed back, or eventually exposed. A wheel cannot be reasoned with because it has no pride to wound. It just keeps spinning over your hopes like a truck tire.
That is all real. I am not pretending the wheel is some lovable goblin. It is brutal, and it can break your body in stupider ways than the rival ever would while turning nourishment into dread at a speed that should alarm any sane person. There will be nights where you stare at the wheel before dinner and feel the same numb terror people feel outside an operating room. That is not trivial. That is your basic relationship to food getting fed through a carnival meat grinder for views.
But when I force myself to choose the worse poison, I keep coming back to authorship.
I can survive random abuse better than intimate redesign, and I would rather be made ridiculous than rewritten by a smug rival building a second brain inside my mouth.
See, the wheel wrecks your days. The rival plan makes a home inside your conscience. The wheel says this round you are eating peanut butter noodles with grape jelly because the audience demanded blood. The rival says the old you was sloppy, swollen, morally unserious, and this elegant little trough of punishment is the adult cure. One of those is a bad night. The other one is an ideology crawling under your skin.
With the wheel, I still get to hate the whole setup cleanly. I get to look at the camera, choke down the abomination, and know with perfect certainty that the thing happening to me is stupid. That clarity is not a small comfort. Clarity keeps rot from turning into faith. It keeps humiliation from dressing up like enlightenment. I may spend half my life burping fish sugar and cursing the studio, but at least I know where the enemy stands. It is painted on a wheel in loud colors for everybody to see.
With the rival diet, the enemy gets to stand behind my own reflection. That is what I cannot accept. I do not want to hear their voice every time I open the fridge or feel my hunger translated through their contempt until I lose the ability to tell whether I am nourishing myself or auditioning for forgiveness. That path feels like the kind of damage that stays after the contract ends. Long after the plan is over, you would still be hearing that bastard whisper through every grocery aisle.
So I pick the wheel.
I pick random disgusting fate over personalized nutritional domination. I pick the vulgar obvious circus over a polished campaign to repossess my instincts. Let the stupid wheel slam around and land on some nightmare plate with steam coming off it while the audience gasps and I gag my way through it knowing exactly what this is. A stupid cruel spectacle is still better than handing my appetite to somebody who hates me enough to call control care.
That's the fucking verdict. I made the call, and if your brain still works, you know where this lands.